Which market value is realistic for the not-on-public-sale nib tester boxes with Montblanc 146 LeGrand, and which nib widths belong in a complete box?

Comparable individual Meisterstücks from such tester boxes were traded around 140 euros; a complete set lay price-wise at around 1,400 euros, without this price having been demonstrably achieved. Into a complete box belong not exclusively 146s but in combination also a 145 with S nib; the S nib width was regularly available but sold poorly and today is regarded as hardly still procurable. Reports exist that the character of the S nib was felt to be too characterless by the then managing director. Tester boxes are particularly sought-after in the US market and find interested buyers there.


Is a Montblanc case won at eBay with an unusual logo a counterfeit, and how can the purchase be reversed?

The case described is a counterfeit; the deviating logo is an unambiguous recognition feature; original cases typically show a clamping for holding the fountain pen. For reversal, the path via PayPal buyer protection is recommended, since the effort is small. With proven counterfeit, the fake status can be confirmed by Montblanc and, if applicable, a complaint filed, since the sale of counterfeits in Germany is punishable. Buyers should carefully check cases before payment, since counterfeiters often make obvious errors on the logo.


What can be done about an increasingly loosening closure cap on a Rotring Initial Silver?

The problem is known and arises through wear of the plastic material inside the cap. A real repair solution does not exist, since Rotring no longer produces the Initial and replacement caps are hardly available. A practical way out is the procurement of further Initial pens via the second-hand market, on which such models were phase-wise available cheaply, in order to use an intact cap from them.


Is a fountain pen acquired at an auction a known Montblanc model?

The pen is a counterfeit. Striking are, among other things, black spaces between the rings as well as a cap form not occurring on originals. In comparison with the original Solitaire Silver Doué or Solitaire Steel Doué, the differences become clearly visible.


How can I recognise whether my Montblanc Meisterstück Classique ballpoint is genuine, and of what does the material really consist?

The Meisterstück writing instruments consist of so-called precious resin, that is, a plastic (similar to plexiglass), not of real natural resin. An exception is the Mozart series, which due to the small wall thickness is made of lacquered metal. Originals typically show a plastic body with metal tip, while counterfeits often consist entirely of lacquered metal. A small chipping behind which yellowish-shimmering material appears can be attributable to the metal tip or simply to ingressed dirt and is no unambiguous authenticity feature. Based on the length and the detail photos, the model number (e.g. 116) can be narrowed down.


How rare is the Montblanc Writers Edition J.S. Bach and in what price range is it traded?

The edition of the J.S. Bach was around 12,000 pieces and is thus below most other Writers Editions, without being really rare. The original list price was about 400 euros in 2001. On the second-hand market, depending on condition and sales platform, prices between approx. 300 and 600 euros are usual; with some patience one finds it on eBay also in the lower range. As with all limited editions, it is traded more rarely with time, simply because fewer pieces change owners.


Do variants of the Montblanc Lorenzo de' Medici exist in which only the body consists of silver?

Of the Lorenzo de' Medici from the Patron of Arts Edition, only a regular variant with octagonal hand-engraved sterling-silver overlay exists; alongside, only a solid-gold version is known. A version with exclusively silver body does not exist. Possibly meant is the Marcel Proust from the Writers Edition: it too has an octagonal sterling-silver overlay but a cap of resin and was made in significantly higher edition than the Medici.


Which Montblanc pencil fits best the Meisterstück Classique Chopin and what differences exist between the models?

Visually, the Meisterstück Classique 165 in the same size best fits the Chopin; the LeGrand would not harmonise proportionally. The LeGrand is a rotary pencil (front-loader) with 0.9 mm lead, which is steplessly advanced; the Classique a push pencil (rear-loader) with 0.5 or 0.7 mm lead. As an alternative for notes and corrections, the Bohème pencil is also suitable, which is compact, has an eraser and is equipped with 0.9 mm lead, which breaks less often. The choice thus depends on look, desired lead thickness and mechanism.


What does the addition N after the model number of a Montblanc Meisterstück mean, e.g. on the 644 N?

The appended N marks on older Meisterstücks the version with wing nib. Models without N are, by contrast, equipped with the classic Meisterstück nib. The distinction is well comprehensible based on the nib illustrations in relevant overviews (e.g. at Maxpens or Penboard).


Where can one acquire the George Washington from the Montblanc series of American presidents?

Such rare Limited Editions turn up regularly in relevant auctions. Alongside eBay, especially the auction houses Bonhams, Bloomsbury Auctions and Christies are suitable, since there high-quality writing instruments are regularly auctioned. Alternatively, a direct enquiry to specialised collector dealers like Paco Cruz (cruzaltpens.com), who has a large range of rare Limited Editions, can be successful.


Which size differences exist between the Montblanc Meisterstück 144 and the 145 regarding barrel diameter and length?

The 145 is somewhat larger than the 144 but retains the proportions of the Classique line. Detailed dimension specifications and comparative illustrations can be viewed in the relevant overviews (e.g. fountainpen.de) as well as in forum posts with concrete dimension tables. The models both belong to the Classique size; the difference is therefore moderate but visible and measurable.


From what period do the models Montblanc 344G and Pix 172 come, and which engraving variants exist?

Of the 344, according to the standard work Collectible Stars, three variants exist: the 344G from the years 1951 to 1953, the 344 from 1954 to 1956 as well as a later version from 1957 to 1960. On the second variant, the star on the cap is merely outlined. The Pix 172 was produced between 1951 and 1958. An originally white-filled engraving can be worn off through use, so it no longer appears coloured today.


From what period does an old box of Montblanc royal-blue ink in a cardboard barrel come?

Royal-blue Montblanc ink in original cardboard packaging with glass barrel is usually dated to the 1950s. A more precise temporal narrowing-down is possible by collectors based on label variants and glass form or based on relevant literature.


How are the numerous supposed Montblanc online shops to be evaluated that offer original goods at strikingly low prices?

They are practically without exception fake shops: either the customer receives no goods at all or a counterfeit, and the credit-card data is misused. Such sites exist in their hundreds and crop up under changing domains. Montblanc pursues corresponding cases via the legal department, but the proceedings drag on. A reliable warning sign is deficient German as well as payment requests by email with attached ZIP files.


Is it normal that a Montblanc 145 Meisterstück appears slightly reddish-transparent when held against strong light?

Yes, the precious resin of the Meisterstücks is slightly transparent against a strong light source and can thereby show a reddish shimmer; this is an authenticity feature. It is to be noted that the material is additionally sensitive to heat. Counterfeits typically consist of lacquered metal and are thereby opaque.


Which Sheaffer model is an unknown auctioned pen?

Based on the auction pictures, the fountain pen can be identified as a Sheaffer Targa in Classic Size, presumably model 1005. A comprehensive overview of the Targa models with illustrations can be found on sheaffertarga.com, where the precise determination can be further secured.


What contents does the report 'Der elfte Finger' in Welt am Sonntag about the fountain-pen specialist Julia Gusano offer, and are the collector statements mentioned therein accurate?

The article portrays Julia Gusano in Madrid and contains historical background on fountain pens, illustrations of her workshop as well as references to historical pieces like the Montblanc Safety 12 with nib prices around 600 euros. The quantities mentioned in the report, however, are to be put into perspective: the claim that only six examples of the Montblanc Safety 12 are still known is, according to collector assessment, incorrect, as is the value statement of 16,000 euros felt to be sensationalist. An illustrated online version with additional background texts appeared in parallel under an alternative title.


How can oddities on a Montblanc Classique Platin Line ballpoint 164P be evaluated, e.g. position of the clip engraving, type of engraving and missing PIX logo?

The engraving under the clip reads on current models 'Made in Germany' instead of 'PIX'; that is therefore inconspicuous. The position of the serial number on the clip edge has been changed several times in the course of production and is therefore no reliable authenticity criterion. The inscription should regularly be a laser engraving; however, current counterfeits also use engravings, so this feature has lost meaning. With the large-capacity refills, variants existed over the years too. For concrete authenticity check, an enquiry to Montblanc Service via the contact form on the website with the complete serial number is recommended.


How is the Marcel Proust pencil correctly filled with leads?

The Proust pencil has the standard mechanism of a Montblanc pencil: the rear cap can be pulled off; behind it the leads are inserted. That when unscrewing the front part the lead visibly protrudes is normal with mechanical pencils and no defect. In an emergency, filling from the front is also possible, by operating the mechanism and pushing the lead in. If the cap sits firmly, it should be carefully pulled off again.


What emerges from the Richemont press release on the possible sale of Montegrappa and on the withdrawal of Norbert Platt?

Richemont has classified the writing-instrument business Montegrappa as a 'discontinued operation' and is actively in sale negotiations. Norbert Platt, who had previously shaped Montblanc decisively and had been CEO of Richemont for five years, announced his withdrawal at the end of the year; later it became known that the resignation took place for health reasons. During his term, group turnover grew to record levels, and operating profit exceeded the one-billion-euro mark. His strategic swing at Montblanc away from the inexpensive writing instrument towards the luxury brand with extended range is regarded across the industry as defining.


Is the brand name Sheaffer correctly spelled or does the variant Shaeffer exist?

The correct spelling is Sheaffer; deviating spellings like Shaeffer are typos and were in the case mentioned corrected.


How can one tell whether a Meisterstück from an unknown source is an original or a counterfeit?

If the writing instrument shown does not correspond to any documented Montblanc model, it is beyond doubt a counterfeit. Typical recognition features of plagiarisms are unusual spaces between the cap rings, deviating inscriptions like 'MONT BLANC' (instead of Montblanc), occasionally even with spelling errors, and nib inscriptions with general terms like 'Iridium Point'. Such pieces are produced in Asia in large numbers at low prices. The designs resemble no really existing model, which eases identification as a fake.


Is a Montblanc pilot's briefcase No. 30860 offered via an internet dealer an original model, and which pilot's briefcases existed at all?

The offered briefcase comes from the years-ago discontinued Solitaire leather collection in matt black soft leather, which should not be confused with the nappa leather of the Platin line. Gilded corners on small leather goods were usual in this series and no indication of a counterfeit. Alongside, pilot's briefcases existed from the 4810 Eastside collection (No. 07578, dimensions 47x35x19 cm) as well as from the Meisterstück line. The Solitaire variant is significantly smaller. Current pilot's briefcases are no longer led by Montblanc in the regular range.


Has Montblanc ever produced a travel trolley, or are corresponding offers counterfeits?

A Montblanc travel trolley does not belong to the official range; corresponding offers are unquestionably counterfeits. At Asian leather-goods fairs, e.g. in Shenzhen, Montblanc-printed bags, cases and trolleys are produced in container loads and distributed via eBay as well as at border markets in Europe. Even sellers with a high rating can offer such plagiarisms commercially; a high rating count is therefore no authenticity indicator.


Did a Montblanc Platinum ballpoint from the series '75 years Passion and Soul' exist, or is it necessarily a counterfeit?

A Platinum variant of the Anniversary Edition '75 Years Passion and Soul' was never produced; offered were exclusively steel and black versions. Further typical fake features are the black case in the packaging, the inside white box (originals are inside black) as well as blurred product photos. Such writing instruments are produced at manufacturing costs of about 10 euros and offered for 100 to 150 dollars as originals. Caution: counterfeiters partly also use real original photos, so pictures alone are no authenticity guarantee.


How does the forum deal with questions that do not belong to the topic of writing instruments, e.g. on acquaintance with Cubans in Germany?

The forum is aimed at writing-instrument collectors; off-topic questions contradict the forum guidelines and are moved by the administrator to the section 'Miscellaneous'. Content-wise, there is no strict restriction, provided a reference to the collector community exists; however, correct categorisation of posts is binding.


How can an older gold-coloured Montblanc ballpoint with the inscription 'No. 88' and lever mechanism on the clip be identified and supplied with refills?

It is the Montblanc 88, a gold-plated ballpoint that, according to Collectible Stars (page 59), was produced between 1961 and 1970. By contrast, the 98 consists of solid gold and was made in 14- and 18-carat variants. The standard work Collectible Stars is available via collectiblestars.de and provides further details. Original refills for the 88 are no longer delivered by Montblanc; alternative refill options have to be procured via collector sources.


How can an inherited Montblanc 149 from the 1950s with the inscription 'Masterpiece' be dated and assessed in value?

The inscription 'Masterpiece' identifies it as an export model that was not intended for the German market. Based on the feed, it can be classified as the second variant of the then 149. The value depends decisively on the condition of the ink window: light, yellowish celluloid points to little use and thereby higher value; dark discolourations reduce it significantly. Before a sale, the fountain pen should be thoroughly flushed. For value orientation, a look at already sold articles on eBay serves; alternatively a sale to specialised collector dealers is possible.


Which writing instruments from the Montblanc editions Writers Edition, Patron of Arts, Artisan and Skeleton are regarded as particularly successful?

Taste questions lead to different favourites, but some models are particularly frequently named. With the Writers Edition, Jules Verne, Schiller, Kafka and Faulkner stand high in favour, although the Verne is regarded as visually balanced but top-heavy in handling. With the Patron of Arts, the Copernicus, the Friedrich II and the Pope Julius II are highlighted; the 888 versions are throughout evaluated as more attractive. From the Artisan editions, the Salvador Dali is particularly valued, which stands close to the skeleton style, followed by the Hundertwasser. Among the Skeletons, the Black Widow is seen narrowly before the Charlie Chaplin, whose availability however is uncertain.


How risky is the purchase of a Montblanc Meisterstück 149 from a Turkish eBay seller without ratings?

The risk is high regardless of whether the auction photos show a real 149. With sellers without ratings from abroad, there is a considerable danger that the delivered goods do not correspond to the description or fail to arrive entirely. Disreputable providers also regularly use foreign photos found via image search, so the illustrations have little meaning. A comparable 149 in coral costs in specialist trade around 900 to 1000 euros; with doubtful offers, distance is to be kept.


Is it normal that on the Delta Dolce Vita Oversize the silver ring between the black end cap and the orange body can be rotated?

No, the silver ring should not be rotatable on the body or the cap; on flawless examples it sits firmly. A loose, rotatable ring indicates a workmanship defect or damage and should be checked by the dealer or manufacturer.


Which model is an inherited Montblanc multi-colour ballpoint, and why does it carry the Montblanc logo although it comes from Fend?

It is presumably a Montblanc 60-series multi-colour ballpoint. These pens were not made by Montblanc itself but by the firm Fend in Pforzheim, which held the patent on the four-colour mechanism; Montblanc sourced the pens and had them labelled under its own name. There existed various variants with different refill counts, depending on Fend production. Such commissioned manufacture was and is common in the industry; even today, mechanisms and accessories are often bought in. For more detailed information, the Fend expert Dirk Barmeier (Penexchange) is a suitable contact.


What distinguishes the Montblanc Bohème Jewels line and why are they rarely to be found on the collector market?

The Bohème Jewels line is relatively new and connected with high retail prices, so buyers are reluctant to part with them, which explains the small presence on the second-hand market. Characteristic are real semi-precious stones like citrine, rhodolite or similar stones as well as a leather sheathing of the body, which makes the pieces appear particularly unusual. Over time, rising collector value is to be expected, since these are real niche products. As with other limited editions of Montblanc, here specific customer needs are specifically addressed.


Which Montblanc fountain pen is equipped with a green semi-precious stone or a cap of green semi-precious material?

Several models show green stones: in the Bohème Vert there is a synthetic emerald in the clip, in the Jungle Eyes collection a tourmaline and in some Patron of Arts editions peridot stones. With the Atelier Privés pieces, real sapphires are used. The cap of the Meisterstück Solitaire Nikolai edition consists of ground and newly bound malachite and was produced in gold and platinum variants. The Nikolai series is no longer being made; remaining stock is available via specialised dealers.


Can in the forum one's own photos be offered as desktop wallpapers for download?

An open upload possibility does not exist, since webspace, technical administration and copyright questions must be clarified. Submitted photos can after coordination by email with confirmation of one's own authorship be sent to the administrator and after review be manually embedded. Owing to the voluntary maintenance, however, publication can occur delayed.


How large is the Montblanc Scott Fitzgerald compared to 146 and 149, and is it suitable for large hands?

The Fitzgerald has roughly the diameter of a 146 but is overall shorter and smaller than the LeGrand. For writers with large hands it is therefore less well suited; a 146 or larger lies more comfortably in the hand.


Are brown discolourations on the Montblanc J.S. Bach and similar oddities on a 149 and Mozart attributable to material defects or storage conditions?

On the J.S. Bach it is no discolouration: Montblanc leads this colour as 'Sepia' and the material is by design dark-brown. Real discolourations or deposit formations on Montblanc writing instruments are, according to collector experience, very rare and can be attributable to unfavourable storage (case materials, humidity, neighbouring materials like furniture outgassing) as well as to inks used. If deposits can be removed with a silver-cleaning cloth or careful wiping, mostly no substance damage is given. For a well-founded judgement, the writing instruments together with the case must be sent in to Montblanc with detailed information on storage location, climate, ink and cleaning.


Which seal is fitted in the Montblanc Rouge et Noir Safety, a cork seal or a modern solution?

Since the Rouge et Noir is conceived as an exact replica of the historical Safety models, it is likely equipped with a cork seal. Cork seals are with proper treatment very long-lasting, especially when the fountain pen is not in use.


How does one tell whether a Montblanc Generation ballpoint acquired via eBay is genuine, and what does the supplied plastic packaging mean?

Based on the features shown, the ballpoint can be classified as an original; obvious counterfeit features are not recognisable. The transparent plastic packaging is an internal shipping packaging that Montblanc uses for delivery to dealers and boutiques; dealers are actually required not to pass it on in sales. An unfilled warranty card is therefore no indication of a counterfeit. Original refills can be reliably obtained via established online shops like missing-pen.de.


Is the gold nib of a Montblanc 246 only with the inscription '4810' and star, without further information like '14C' or '585', original?

The nib depicted is likely genuine but does not regularly belong in the 246: it looks like a Meisterstück nib from the 1930s, recognisable by the small logo hallmark under the main logo. On a regular 246 nib, 'MONTBLANC', the logo, '14C', again 'MONTBLANC' and '585' should be stamped. An exception are France models: since France only recognises gold from 18 carat, writing instruments sold there were delivered with 18-carat nibs, partly by drawing on old stock of Meisterstück nibs. Thus the nib can also be correct in a 246 destined for France.


How are the German and English Wikipedia articles on Montblanc to be evaluated in content, and should forum members contribute to them?

The German Wikipedia entry on Montblanc International GmbH offers a compact overview and milestones, while the English article ('Montblanc pens') is clearly capable of being expanded. Topics like the change of model ranges (early celluloid series, Generation, Bohème, StarWalker), the takeover by Richemont, the gold-nib production, the piston system and the Atelier Artisan could be supplemented. Since Wikipedia is open, anyone can supplement contributions; references to existing overview pages should be retained. The Montblanc Museum, which is mentioned in some contributions, is located in the Hamburg plant and is accessible within the framework of factory inspections.


How is a Montblanc StarWalker Rubber Line offered on eBay at a strikingly low price to be evaluated, even if the pictures look like an original?

Strikingly cheap offers are most likely counterfeits or fraud attempts. Sellers often use original photos but deliver plagiarisms; especially Chinese online shops use picture material of real writing instruments. A second variant is identity theft: hacked eBay accounts are misused for mass phantom sales; the money goes to the perpetrators. Indications are many identical expensive sets with one seller with few, exclusively buyer ratings. If needed, payment should be made exclusively via PayPal with credit card in order to keep both refund routes open; in case of doubt, the purchase is to be refrained from.


Which model and which value are an inherited antique Montblanc fountain pen from family possession?

It is a Meisterstück from the 1930s, based on the indications given presumably a 25. The exact model number is embossed at the rear on the turning knob of the filling mechanism. It is a push-knob filler with an ink sac inside; after long non-use, the sac typically has to be renewed, for which specialised restorers like Horst Schrage (max@maxpens.de) offer themselves. For value determination, the relevant collector guides and a comparison with current eBay auctions are recommended; 25s are not rare, so patience in market observation is sensible.


How can serial fake sellers be recognised on eBay who distribute plagiarisms over a longer time?

Repeat offenders are often recognisable by using the same product photos for months and only changing the seller name. Occasionally, providers combine an original photo with a second shot that, however, shows a plagiarism; decisive are fine differences e.g. in the grooves or inscriptions. Even sellers who unintentionally take over picture material from foreign auctions can distribute plagiarisms. A careful picture analysis and comparison with documented originals are therefore indispensable.


Since when is the Montblanc StarWalker Cool Blue available and what is the price difference compared to the Resin variant based on?

The StarWalker Cool Blue was already announced in 2004 but only actually came into trade in May 2007. The intense blue colouring acts in the original more vigorously and partly slightly translucent, which on photos is hardly reproducible. The price premium of around 100 euros over the Resin model results from the more elaborate manufacturing process of the coloured variant. A sound technical justification of the price difference is not provided by the manufacturer.


Must the writing instruments of a Marcel Proust Limited Edition set bear identical edition numbers, and are early Limited Editions possibly without numbering?

On an original set, all three writing instruments bear the same edition number; only then is, from a collector perspective, a complete set with corresponding value present. If the numbers are different, the set was subsequently put together, which reduces the collector value to the respective individual value. Particularly unusual is when the pencil delivered only in the set deviates. Early Limited Editions without numbering are possible; this should, however, in the individual case be confirmed by Montblanc.


What is an ebonite feed and where do its advantages and disadvantages lie compared to feeds of plastic?

Ebonite is hard rubber, a natural rubber cross-linked through high sulphur shares, which is coloured black through soot additions. Modern feeds mostly consist of polyamide (Nylon, Delrin) and are produced by injection moulding, while ebonite feeds have to be mechanically cut. Ebonite shows better adhesion properties for ink, which is why enthusiasts prefer traditionally made ebonite feeds. A precisely constructed plastic feed can, however, be functionally equivalent or even superior; decisive remain the precision of lamellas and capillaries. The appeal of the ebonite feed thus also lies in the craft demand and in the image.


How is the Conklin Mark Twain Crescent Filler in the model 'Zebra' to be classified technically and in writing terms?

The Zebra is part of the reissue of the Mark Twain Crescent Filler series and is turned from a solid acrylic-resin block and hand-polished. It is a sac filler with the characteristic crescent push button together with safety ring; closed it measures about 14.3 cm and weighs about 32 grams. Fitted is a black stainless-steel nib, here in strength M, combined with a sprung clip. It lies balanced in the hand, writes immediately and without failure and tolerates also longer lying open without drying out.


How is a clogged Montblanc click pencil 251 made workable again, and how is it correctly filled with leads?

Basically, Montblanc pencils can be filled from the front by operating the mechanism and pushing the lead in. If a lead remains stuck in the barrel or the mechanism can no longer be pushed through, this indicates a jammed lead piece that must be carefully removed. Since the forum has not been actively maintained since 2007, an additional enquiry in the active Penexchange forum is worthwhile, which also covers pencils and mechanism topics. The standard leads available in 60 mm are generally suitable for such models.


How can a Montblanc fountain pen Simplo No. 0 with the nib hallmark 'Simplo 0 14k' be identified and assessed in value?

It is the Montblanc No. 0, a historical model from the early days of the brand; the digit denotes the size and stands for the second-smallest version (smaller was only the 00). Such early Simplo pieces are regarded as impressive and valuable. An eBay search helps only restrictedly with this model rarity; meaningful value statements are provided by experienced collectors. For a well-founded evaluation or a fair sale, an enquiry to Horst Schrage (max@maxpens.de), known for fair purchase offers, is recommended.


Does eBay really offer a telephone service hotline with personal contact persons?

Yes, eBay has introduced a customer service with a telephone hotline (01805 - 626 000), which is secured via a customer-specific service PIN. On call, users are identified by name based on the eBay account name. The service is initially in a test phase in which only selected users have access; an extension to all members is planned. A prior verification of the email (e.g. via the My eBay inbox or by forwarding to spoof@) is advisable in order to exclude phishing.


How can the Montblanc 75 Years of Passion and Soul (Ballpoint 164) be verified as an original, and are the unfamiliar imprints on cap and clip typical of authenticity?

With the Anniversary Edition 75 Years of Passion and Soul, there are body and nib versions whose engravings do not look exactly like the standard Meisterstück. Thus the Pix imprint on the inside of the clip can appear with an inconspicuous (R) and the cap embossing read only 'Montblanc-Meisterstück-' without the Pix addition. These features are confirmed as correct through comparison with the sister model 144. With remaining doubts, an authenticity check in a Montblanc boutique is recommended, which brings final certainty.


What does the inscription Montblanc-Meisterstück-Pix(R) on the cap of a 146 Le Grand mean and is this embossing normal?

The cap inscription with the component Pix(R) is normal on Meisterstück models like the 146 Le Grand and has been usual for decades. Pix is a historical brand name protected by Montblanc, which goes back to the ballpoint mechanism and appears as a trademark-secured addition on the caps. Background can be found in the more in-depth articles on the brand history of the house.


How are the properties of the Waldmann Pocket in sterling silver/black to be assessed regarding filling, nib and writing behaviour?

The Waldmann Pocket in black/sterling silver 925 is a compact cartridge fountain pen with plug-on cap; a converter does not fit due to the short inner barrel length. The nib is a steel nib by Schmidt (Iridium Point), available in M. In practical testing, the pen shows a regular, saturated ink flow, no start-up difficulties even after longer non-use or open storage and lies well in the hand despite the slim barrel when written with the cap posted. Dimensions: 12 cm closed, 13.5 cm with the cap posted.


Which high-quality fineliner alternatives to Montblanc StarWalker and Stabilo 88 exist, and are the fineliner refills of various manufacturers interchangeable?

The fineliner refills by Montblanc, Faber-Castell (e.g. Graf-von-Faber-Castell roller) and many other manufacturers are made by Schmidt Technology and are largely identical in construction. Apart from the refill end and the thread, they correspond to the Euro standard for rollerball refills and can therefore be used in most housings that use this standard. The selection of brands and models with Schmidt fineliner refills is thereby very large. On the topic of choosing writing instruments for left-handers, personal trying-out in the shop is decisive, since the writing behaviour strongly depends on individual pen posture.


Is a Hommage à Chopin with silver instead of gold trim a counterfeit, and how can a hesitant ink flow on broad nibs be remedied?

The Hommage à Chopin also exists as a Platinum variant with platinum-plated/silver-looking trim; a silver-banded Chopin is therefore not necessarily a counterfeit but often the more expensive Platinum version. Problems with the ink flow can generally be adjusted in a Montblanc boutique. Before that, the attempt with other inks (e.g. blue from Lamy, Pelikan or Montblanc) is worthwhile, since the flow properties vary significantly. Failures with broad nibs (B/BB) are frequent at first, since Montblanc nibs are flat and not strongly rounded ground; 'breaking in' concerns rather the hand than the pen. If the problem remains after several weeks, an examination by service is sensible.


How does one recognise high-quality Montblanc counterfeits, e.g. of Special Editions like the Writers Edition?

Even optically deceptive counterfeits can be identified by detail features: non-gilded cap and body rings, wrong feed, steel instead of gold nib as well as a packaging not matching the edition. Even individually-appearing clip numbers and nearly correct stars are now being imitated. Counterfeits predominantly occur with cartridge fillers; piston fillers like Writers Edition models are more elaborate to copy and thus comparatively rarely counterfeited – but occasionally yes. To minimise risk, purchase from a Montblanc boutique or an established specialist retailer is recommended instead of from unknown online providers.


What should be considered when buying a used mechanical typewriter from the build year 1960 regarding ribbons and function?

With mechanical typewriters from the 1960s, strike differences are to be expected that arise with a soiled or jammed typebar segment and can be remedied through a service; later golfball typewriters do not have this problem. Ink ribbons are not generally standardised but, depending on the model, still available in specialist trade. Before purchase of a concrete model (mentioned was e.g. a Privileg 160T), research on spare-parts supply and, if applicable, cleaning/service of the mechanism by an office-machine mechanic is worthwhile.


What does the positive business development of the Swatch Group say about the situation of the luxury sector and about the collector segment?

The Swatch Group makes its profit above all in the luxury segment with brands like Breguet, Glashütte Original, Blancpain or Rado, while the brand Swatch itself loses market share in the low-price area against competitors like Fossil or fashion brands (Esprit); a spin-off or rebranding was even considered. The positive group development is therefore no unambiguous indicator of an upturn in the classical luxury market. For collectors, the example shows how strongly collector numbers and values depend on the economic development of the brand: with Swatch, collector prices of formerly sought-after pieces have fallen significantly.


Which Montblanc model is an old writing set in a leather case with the imprint linea bianca, and did this model have a gold nib?

The set corresponds to the Montblanc Slim Line series from the 1970s/80s, recognisable by the star on the clip; the leather case with the imprint 'linea bianca', however, presumably does not come from Montblanc itself. Slim Line models had exclusively gilded steel nibs, never real gold nibs – a frequent confusion with the externally similar Noblesse series, which had real gold nibs. The value of the Slim Line models is limited; comparison values are best ascertained via current auctions, with the search term 'Montblanc' broadly set and the exclusion principle used. A chargeable value determination is offered e.g. by Stefan Wallrafen.


What is known about Ric Lei Safety fountain pens from Leipzig, and can a crack on the hard-rubber body be repaired?

Ric Lei was founded by a former Montblanc employee (Richter) in Leipzig and produced qualitatively high-grade writing instruments in the style of a Montblanc octagonal Safety with heart-hole nib; detail information on the brand is rare and predominantly documented in collectors' forums. Hard rubber cannot be reliably glued; a cracked component must be newly made. For such repairs, reference is made to specialised workshops, e.g. Horst from maxpens.de.


How can the authenticity be secured when buying a Montblanc Solitaire Carbon/Steel ballpoint on eBay if the seller has only few ratings?

Even if the photo shown depicts a real Montblanc, that says nothing about the goods actually sent; more problematic than crude counterfeits are today virtual offers (sellers with few ratings, prepayment, identical texts/pictures). Sensible safeguards are the express question about originality, the offer of cash payment on collection and the written authenticity guarantee. If the seller refuses collection and gives no clear authenticity assurance, a purchase at higher amounts is to be advised against.


When was the TV report on Stefan Fink and his workshop in the magazine K1 Journal aired on Kabel 1?

The report on Stefan Fink, originally announced for 6 September 2005, was postponed by Kabel 1 at short notice by around four weeks. As the new broadcast date in the magazine K1 Journal, Friday, 28.10.2005 at 18:45 was named.


How reliable are condition specifications in eBay auctions for high-quality writing instruments and what strategies minimise the risk?

Condition descriptions like 'good condition' or 'near-mint' are often strongly glossed over by private sellers; PayPal generally does not intervene with condition defects, provided the consignment counts as delivered. Known commercial collector dealers are by contrast reliable but mostly run their own shops outside eBay at often cheaper prices than in the auctions – direct enquiries are worthwhile. Compared with realistic collector prices at pen shows, eBay prices for used and rare pieces frequently lie significantly excessive. Recommended are detailed photos and descriptions on buying and selling as well as a basically sceptical attitude towards unknown private sellers.


Which Montblanc models are three inherited writing instruments with 925/750 hallmarks, a lapis lazuli look and a solid-gold body?

The gold pen is a 144 Solid Gold with 18kt overlay from the early to mid-1990s; later solid-gold models show a herringbone pattern of yellow and white gold, the gold layer is thin and the material value moderate, but the models are comparatively rare. The lapis rollerball is a 163 Solitaire Ramses II with lapis-lazuli cap and gilded silver body (vermeil). The third piece is a 144 Ramses II whose thin lapis-lazuli cap (frequent defect of the range) had broken and was subsequently sheathed in wood/horn by a third party – an unofficial DIY job, no Montblanc original state.


Does an old wristwatch inscribed 'Montblanc' come from the Hamburg writing-instrument manufacturer, and does it have a watch history before 1997?

Before 1997, Montblanc Simplo GmbH did not produce watches; older watches with the inscription 'Montblanc' come from an independent Swiss watchmaker, which is now insolvent. When Montblanc Hamburg entered watch production, the trademark rights for the watch name 'Montblanc' were bought from a Swiss watchmaker, whereby Hamburg has been allowed to appear in the watch segment under its own star since 1997. From a pure collector's view of Montblanc writing instruments, the old Swiss watches are not relevant; their historical value and their connection to the brand history can nevertheless be interesting.


Does a subsequent diamond decoration on a Montblanc Kafka from the Writers Edition reduce the collector value?

Subsequent modifications like applied diamonds on collector writing instruments are a matter of taste: supporters see it as a creative enhancement; critics complain about the loss of original symmetry and evaluate the conspicuous jewellery as a pure status signal. From a collector's view, it is no longer the original state, which generally reduces the value for classical collectors.


Is the use of the term 'Meisterstück' in the advertising of other manufacturers (e.g. Garmin) trademark-problematic for Montblanc?

The term 'Meisterstück' is in general language a quality term and no exclusively Montblanc-protected brand name; in trademark law there is a need to keep it free, which is why other companies may advertise with it. The trademark-law assessment can however vary in the individual case, especially with very similar handwritten design the topic of reputation exploitation could be discussed, as comparable domain and trademark disputes show. For the broad population, 'Meisterstück' is moreover not primarily associated with Montblanc but generally understood as an award of craftsmanlike top quality, so confusion danger is mostly not given.


Does the Waterman Sérénité in wood also exist as a rollerball or ballpoint?

With the black Sérénité variant, the nib unit is exchangeable for a ballpoint or rollerball module; the barrels are not model-specifically fixed. It is therefore likely that this is also possible with the wood version; a direct enquiry to the manufacturer is recommended in order to clarify it bindingly.


Are frequent defects on cap thread, nib and body of a Montblanc StarWalker fountain pen typical, and how does Montblanc react with repairs outside the warranty?

On the StarWalker, the cap thread is inside of plastic, while the barrel thread consists of metal; with too firm tightening, the plastic thread can give way over time. Repeated defects of the same components are, however, not the rule. The warranty does not automatically extend through a repair; after expiry, the customer bears the costs, which for a cap can be around 120 euros. Goodwill is a matter of negotiation and to be weighed entrepreneurially between prior pricing-in of possible repairs and individual assumption of costs.


How can the grooves of a platinum-plated StarWalker Doué be cleaned without damaging the coating?

For gentle cleaning of the grooves and the platinum-plated surface, a soft brush is suitable, e.g. a soft toothbrush or the cleaning brush of an electric shaver, lightly moistened. Cloths alone do not reach the recesses sufficiently. Important is to keep mechanical stress low in order to avoid scratches on the platinum plating.

General questions on writing instruments


Does a Montblanc Leonard Bernstein exist as a cartridge filler with decorated body and silver clip?

Such a variant of the Leonard Bernstein Montblanc has never produced; the writing instrument shown is unambiguously a counterfeit, presumably of Chinese origin. Recognisable is this, among other things, by nib, feed, clip, grip section and 'converter', which do not correspond to the original features of Montblanc. The real Leonard Bernstein is designed as a piston filler with a gold clip.


Which inks are suitable for a Sheaffer White Dot Triumph Sentinel from 1949, and is special treatment necessary after long idle time?

For historical Sheaffer models, exclusively water-soluble, non-sticking inks should be used; classic Pelikan 4001 Royal Blue and blue Faber-Castell ink are regarded as unproblematic. Pigmented or strongly coloured inks (black, red, iron-gall) are to be avoided, since they can attack the material. Before first putting it into operation, thorough flushing with tap water is recommended; regular flushing keeps the pen permanently functional.


What should be considered when buying a Montblanc Chopin (M145) as a gift, especially regarding nib width and eBay risks?

Decisive for later use is the right nib width that fits the writing habits of the gift recipient; otherwise the fountain pen remains unused. Before purchase, an inconspicuous test with other fountain pens is therefore recommended to determine the preferred line thickness. When buying from an established Montblanc dealer, the nib can typically be exchanged within 14 days; on eBay this safety net is not given, which is why caution is advised with private sellers and especially with providers with few ratings.


What is known about the Montblanc models Meisterstück 12 and No. 38 from the 1960s?

Both models were made between 1959 and 1968. The Meisterstück 12 is the smaller Meisterstück fountain pen with piston filler and so-called butterfly nib; the No. 38 a ballpoint (not a rollerball) of the third line below the Meisterstück range. In black standard colour both models are relatively frequently preserved and accordingly not particularly valuable; collector prices reach especially deviating colour versions.


What does the 'S' in the mountain imprint on the cap of the first Montblanc Meisterstück edition (25) mean?

The 'S' in the broader mountain imprint of early Meisterstücks stands for 'Simplo' and refers to the company history: Montblanc emerged from the Simplo Filler Pen Company and later operated as Montblanc Simplo GmbH. In the later Meisterstück generations this 'S' was dropped; likewise the nib engravings were changed from '18 ct' to '4810' and cap rings supplemented.


How high are the repair costs at Montblanc when on a 144 a body crack and gold abrasion at the cap cone occur, and is this a justified defect?

With a justified material defect, Montblanc service generally takes over the repair free of charge; otherwise the flat rate 1 of 49 euros applies. Cracks in the barrel, peeling gold layer on the cap/nib ring or similar material defects should therefore be sent to service for assessment. Before shipping, cleaning, water-based rinsing and inspection are recommended; further factual information on scratches in the lacquer was not added in the thread.


Is the Montblanc Noblesse Oblige correctly named, or does 'oblique' refer to the nib form?

The model is officially called 'Noblesse Oblige'; the name plays on the saying 'noblesse oblige' (nobility obliges) and has nothing to do with the nib form. An obliquely ground nib would be called 'oblique', which is often confused with 'oblige'. Of the Noblesse Oblige, an older and a more recent version exist, distinguishable by logo and clip design. With authenticity checking of used-bought pieces, the front of the original nib is decisive; the feed is rarely subsequently retrofitted to fit.


How is a bulk-filler prototype of polycarbonate with embedded quail-egg shells optimally implemented in design terms, especially regarding ink-view window and shell distribution?

For a better feel, it is recommended to place the eggshells more densely so that a three-dimensional effect arises through overlaps and the partial transparency does not seem 'undecided'. Instead of a continuously semi-transparent body, a clearly delimited ink-view window (densely above, running out towards the viewing window, or a separate small window) is visually more coherent. A screw cap on the filling grip requires a diameter-reduction step on the thread part, which is structurally a disadvantage. Hints on processing eggshell surfaces are also offered by Horst from maxpens.de, who has extensive experience with this technique.


Which Montblanc Meisterstück model bears the embossing D.R.P. 652405 as well as 4810/M/250 on the nib?

The nib inscription correctly reads 4810 (not 1810); this figure marks the height of Mont Blanc and is standard on Meisterstück nibs. For an unambiguous model determination based on the D.R.P. number and the imprint details, a photo is necessary. The further discussion was moved into a separate thread.


What are the causes of writing failures of a Montblanc 162 rollerball in certain writing angles, and can a fineliner refill provide a remedy?

Roller- and ballpoints regulate the ink flow via the ball in the tip, which simultaneously acts as a limitation; the sharp edges of the tip lead to tight tolerances in the writing angle. Failures can indicate a too dry refill or a slightly bent tip edge. A switch to another refill, e.g. a broader ballpoint refill or a Schmidt fineliner refill, can improve the ink flow and ease the angle range, since the 162 barrels accept both rollerball and fineliner refills.


Why are historical Montblanc Safety fountain pens often falsely offered in trade and on eBay as 'compressor', and what should be considered when buying?

Safety fountain pens and compressor fountain pens have different filling systems; a movable, extendable nib is unambiguous identification of a Safety pen and rules out a compressor. Even employees of regular specialist shops often do not know historical writing instruments sufficiently, which is why wrong information frequently occurs, on which sellers then rely. Collectors should therefore check models themselves or verify via relevant collector forums and specialist literature. Additionally, secondary defects like wrong nib or wrong cap sleeve can further reduce the value, which is why high prices for such pieces are mostly not justified.


Are older Montblanc Meisterstücks without serial number (146 converter, ballpoint, pencil) necessarily counterfeits, and what does the clip engraving 'W-Germany' or 'Germany' mean?

The absence of a serial number is no indication of a counterfeit, since Montblanc introduced serial numbers only relatively late; counterfeits today often even bear fictitious numbers. A 146 without platinum intarsia on the nib usually indicates production in the 1980s. The clip engraving 'W-Germany' stands for manufacture before reunification 1990, 'Germany' for later production. Further detail features can be compared via the historical model descriptions on fountainpen.de.


Which Montblanc model is a Meisterstück with 'Hermes' engraving, nib inscription 4310/140/585 and warranty slip 13 400?

It is a Meisterstück 144 from the 1950s with a promotional embossing 'Hermes' (promotional gift to business customers, no reference to the brand Hermès or Hermes abrasives). The nib engraving reads 4810/14C/585 (height of Mont Blanc and gold content); the model emerges from the number on the piston end (142, 144, 146 or 149); on the turning knob of the piston, often the nib width is noted (e.g. OBB). The dating to the 1950s takes place on the basis of the celluloid material and the non-melted-in, loosely sitting cap rings – from the 1960s the bodies consist of plastic with melted-in rings. The 144 was produced from 1949 to 1960; the model numbers 13 400 and 13 200 from the 90s warranty papers therefore do not fit this fountain pen.


Does a Montblanc Bohème Steel ballpoint exist, and what price is appropriate for a used example in mediocre condition?

The Bohème Steel ballpoint exists; compared to the black precious-resin variant, it is significantly more expensive (new price around 690 euros). The value on the second-hand market depends strongly on the polishing condition: if scratches can be polished out, the purchase can be worthwhile; deeper damage on metal models can expose the coating, and a complete replacement by Montblanc is in such cases very expensive. For a near-scratch-free example, a price around 240 euros counts as a bargain, while offers in worn condition are to be critically checked.


How rare is a DEF nib (Durchschreibefeder, extra fine) on a Pelikan 400NN, and does it influence the resale value?

Durchschreibefedern (D nibs) on Pelikan 400NN are not exceptionally rare and occur regularly on the market. The nib variant alone has experience-shown only small price influence, since the majority of collectors prefer soft nibs; a noteworthy premium can only be achieved if a buyer specifically searches for a hard nib. On sale, the DEF characteristic should nevertheless be stated in order to specifically address interested writers.


What is a set of the brand Markant with several metal nib tips, a plastic pen with metal clip and accessory parts?

The description points to a drawing pen or India-ink pen set for architects and technical drawers, on which the metal tips serve different line widths. An unambiguous assignment, however, requires photos. With classical calligraphy, such sets have nothing to do.


What to do about ink leakage at the turning knob of a Montblanc 342, and can Montblanc service still repair this model today?

The 342 was a historical standard fountain pen, produced in large numbers; repairs via Montblanc itself are often disproportionately expensive compared to the market value. More sensible is repair by specialised restorers, who are listed in the repair lists of collector forums. Before the investment, the economic value of the writing instrument should be weighed against the repair costs; pigmented inks like 'Midnight Blue' should anyway be avoided in old holders.


How is the quality of the Sailor 1911 fountain pens with 21K Togi and Music Nib nibs to be assessed?

The Sailor 1911 models offer outstanding writing quality; especially the 21K Togi and Music nibs deliver a characteristic and very pleasant writing image. In overall impression, the writing instruments, however, appear rather plain; the housing of firm, acceptably scratch-resistant plastic does not stand out visually strongly from standard products, which is why the haptic 'wow effect' compared to some other brands is smaller. A pre-ordered nib adjustment (e.g. via Mottishaw) can further improve the writing impression.


How is a sale offer for a Montblanc L139 (M nib) to be placed at the right place, and which information on condition and price are necessary?

Sale offers for writing instruments belong in the forum section 'For Sale' and not in general discussion areas. Sensible is the supplementation with a photo (maximum 499 pixels wide) as well as concrete information on condition and price expectation, so interested parties can judge the offer.


How high are the current list prices (status 2008/2009) of the Montblanc Meisterstück Classique and Le Grand twist-action ballpoints in gilded and platinum-plated version?

At the Münster dealer the following prices applied: Classique twist ballpoint with gold trim 265 euros, platinum 275 euros; Le Grand twist ballpoint with gold trim 285 euros, platinum 295 euros. For comparison: in 2006 the Le Grand Platinum was at 270 euros, the gold Le Grand at 255 euros. Telephone price enquiries and occasional discount requests are frequently successful in MB shops. With purchase from commercial eBay providers under shop price, restricted or missing international manufacturer's warranty is to be reckoned with; campaigns like 10 percent Payback at Kaufhof can compensate the price difference with the internet.


How can an S.T. Dupont money clip in palladium be checked for authenticity, and is a price around 300 euros for four pieces realistic?

S.T. Dupont counterfeits, especially in lighters and accessories, are technically often very high-quality, which is why a missing serial number or precious-metal hallmark alone is no unambiguous authenticity indication; the 'Made in England' stamp is, however, unusual for a French brand and should be questioned. Since the model is to be found neither via Google nor in the official product database, it is likely an older or already discontinued variant. For verification, it is recommended to send photos directly to S.T. Dupont or to involve specialised accessories forums before a purchase in larger quantities.


Is a manufacturer like Parker allowed to use three cap rings, or is this design trademark-protected for Montblanc?

Protected by trademark law for Montblanc is only the special combination of two narrow rings and one broader middle ring, but not three equally strong rings. Manufacturers with their own historical production of such ring combinations (e.g. Aurora, OMAS) may use these again in reissues. With the Parker Duofold, three cap rings already existed when Montblanc still used single- and twin-ring caps; an objection by Montblanc is therefore not possible.


Which fountain pen in the range 100–150 euros is suitable as a replacement for a Pelikan IBIS Günther Wagner that offers a somewhat grippier surface and a stable, pressure-resistant nib?

Recommended is the Pelikan M200 as a successor replica in this price class with classical appearance and good nib stability. The M200 with DEF nib offers an extra-fine carbon-copy nib that tolerates strong pressing – suitable for a pressure-rich, fast writing image. Pelikan nibs are overall stable, so even with a vigorous writing style no problems arise. More in-depth Pelikan-specific recommendations can be found additionally in specialised Pelikan forums.


Which brand model is a school pen from 1992 with a vividly red cap (with name plate), silver nib, grip section with notches, light wooden barrel and red end ball?

The description fits the Lamy school writing pen (Lamy ABC), a classical model of the Lamy writing-learning system with ergonomically notched grip section, exchangeable name plate on the cap and wooden barrel. Further information on the model and the writing-learning system can be found on the Lamy website.


Are the Manufactum upper-school exercise book and the folded letters offered there suitable for writing with a fountain pen?

On the upper-school exercise book itself, no experience values were available in the thread. The folded letters bleed strongly when written on with a fountain pen, so the ink looks ugly on the outside-visible address area. For a presentable inscription, ballpoint, pencil or roller is therefore recommended. The paper of the folded letters is thus not fountain-pen-suitable.


How should one react to a suspicious-looking eBay offer that is possibly a counterfeit or a hacked seller account?

With suspicious offers, a direct enquiry to the supposed seller is worthwhile, since accounts are regularly used by third parties and articles posted without the owner's knowledge. Before a transfer, the purchase should be aborted. PayPal indeed offers in case of justified complaints like counterfeits a refund, but the procedures are lengthy and connected with writing effort. In case of doubt, the purchase is to be refrained from.


Who will the Patron of the Arts Edition 2006 be dedicated to?

The Patron of the Arts Edition 2006 is dedicated to Sir Henry Tate.


Is a Montblanc with only "Montblanc Germany" on the cap edge a 121, and did it also exist as a cartridge filler?

The Montblanc 121 was, according to the relevant literature (Collectible Stars by Stefan Wallrafen), made exclusively as a piston filler. A cartridge-filler variant is not documented; therefore the suspicion is close that it is a mixed assembly, e.g. with a body of a 220 and a cap from the 121. A counterfeit is with these editions practically ruled out, since they are uninteresting for counterfeiters. Ultimately the variant remains difficult to unambiguously assign.


What do the engraving "universo" and the abbreviation "PL" on a Montblanc 432 Stylo mean?

"universo" is most likely an individual promotional or gift engraving, as was usual on Montblanc writing instruments as corporate gifts; an official register of such engravings does not exist. The abbreviation "PL" does not denote the material but the colour or the celluloid of body and cap (platin-lined) and has nothing to do with platinum as metal. The 432 is a stylo, that is, a writer without nib, with a steel tube and a silver rod inside that controls the ink supply via capillary action. Stylos offered the advantage that document-proof inks could also be used, which would have gummed up a fountain pen.


From what period does a Montblanc Pix 283 pencil come, and is a restoration sensible?

The Montblanc Pix 283 was made between 1954 and 1959. With signs of use like small scratches, much can be achieved with polish. More difficult is a worn-off gilding, which mostly requires a professional re-gilding. With the disassembly of older Pelikan or Montblanc models, utmost caution is in order; without experience, releasing the upper part oneself is basically advised against.


How is the Montblanc Hommage à Max Reinhardt Edition 2011 designed, and how is it judged?

The Edition 2011 is designed with tiger eye as the decorative stone, whose characteristic structure, however, hardly comes into its own on press photos. While the workmanship is evaluated as successful, the design is regarded, compared to the Reinhardt editions of earlier years, as less convincing. Tastes here diverge, and the edition is anyway aimed at a special target group.


How is a Montblanc Meisterstück with 14ct gold nib (star with 35) and moving piston mechanism to be classified, whose description turns out scant?

The writing instrument described is apparently a so-called Bastard, that is, an assemblage of at least three not-matching parts. The cap presumably comes from a 136, the nib from an even older model and the barrel probably from a 246. In this constellation, the components are only usable as spare parts, but not as a complete, original-true collector's piece.


How rare is the Montblanc Artisan Collection White Pearl or Magic Beauty II Mozart set, and what was the original retail price?

The White Pearl or Magic Beauty II sets are regarded as exceptionally rare and were in 2003 led only in a few boutiques; the edition of the Mozart sets is said to be in the two-digit range, that of the 144/164 somewhat higher. A purchase price of 750 euros for a Mozart set is classified as very cheap. The original retail price was, according to boutique information, around 860 euros for the 144/164 variant. The claim that the set is already 15 years old is wrong; correct is the first issue May 2003. Because of low demand and unfavourable dollar exchange rate, it is currently rather advised to hold than to sell.


Has Montblanc produced writing instruments without the characteristic star on the cap?

Yes, such writing instruments exist. They were made for the Arab market, since the star there evoked unwanted associations; therefore the trademark was modified or omitted. Examples are found already in the 50s and 60s. In Germany these variants turn up only rarely, e.g. on eBay. On the value, the absence of the star has, by collector experience, no significant influence; for some collectors such pieces are even particularly interesting.


Which model is an old Montblanc with 14C/585 nib, flat feed and no inscription on the turning knob, presumably 334 or 334 1/2?

Based on the features, a mixed model is likely present: the cap probably comes from the 334 1/2, the body from the 344. Two cap rings point to a cap of the second price series, while clip and cap crown (engraved instead of white-inlaid star) are to be assigned to the third series. The components thus do not belong to a uniform original model.


Will the Montblanc Cardinal Richelieu (Limited Artisan Edition, retail price 13,500 euros) gain in value in future?

The Richelieu belongs to the Limited Artisan Edition, which is not actively marketed by Montblanc. Owing to the high issue prices and the narrow collector circle, the value can after the first sale initially fall, especially with quick resale e.g. via eBay. Well-marketed, e.g. via auction houses, higher prices are possible. Ranges like Writers Edition or Patron of the Arts benefit more strongly from collectors who aim for complete series; with Skeleton and Artisan editions this is hardly possible due to high prices and small quantities. A reliable value forecast is not possible; a pleasing design and low limitation can have a positive effect.


How everyday-suitable is the Montblanc StarWalker Rubber & Metal, and is an expensive repair worthwhile?

With careful transport in cases, hardly any problems are to be expected; in the grooves, however, through reaction with skin sweat an oxide layer can form that is mostly easy to remove. Problems with the rubber surface are known but not universal. A repair, e.g. with a defective cap thread, is only worthwhile if one wishes to continue to use the writing instrument; after the exchange, warranty on the replaced parts again exists. As an alternative, Pelikan was discussed; the ductus does not appeal to everyone; personally the StarWalker was preferred.


How is an eBay offer of a Montblanc Mozart set from a dealer without specialist-trade status to be evaluated?

On the photos, no signs of a counterfeit are recognisable; the set appears original. The assured two-year warranty, however, is problematic, since this can actually only be granted by authorised specialist retailers, who may not sell on eBay. Such offers often come from foreclosure sales of former specialist retailers or from clearance sales of office-furnishing houses that have discontinued the writing-instrument business. A warranty via the manufacturer is in such cases not to be expected.


How is a Montblanc fountain pen without model number in the cap ring, with a gilded steel nib without 585 hallmark to be classified?

The writing instrument is officially not a 221, since the 221 always had a particular gold nib. An early model of the "Generation" 13100 can also be ruled out, since these had a model number in the cap ring and also a gold nib. The "Classic" line or older writing instruments from the third series come into question; the latter, however, had only one cap ring. The missing 585 hallmark unambiguously points to a gilded steel nib, which supports the classification as a cheaper model.


Is there a list or source from which one can read the availability and current market prices of Montblanc Limited Editions?

A central, complete list does not exist. Larger stocks are kept by specialist retailers like Scription, whose offers and prices, however, are non-binding and quickly changing. For realistic value determination, it is recommended to search on eBay for completed auctions worldwide in order to see actually achieved sales prices. The auction prices stated by Montblanc on its own website often deviate significantly from eBay prices. Generally: some editions like the Hemingway retain their value close to the RRP; others like the J.P. Morgan are to be had under RRP.


What background information is there on the Montblanc Pope Black & White fountain pen?

The Pope Black & White had a launch price of 37,000 euros and counts accordingly as a high-priced, very exclusive piece. With a purchase in the USA at low dollar exchange rate, a price advantage could theoretically arise; however, on import into Germany, customs fees apply that can quickly eat up the advantage. Substantial further background information was not mentioned in the thread.


Which classy case for a Montblanc 145 is recommendable that does not consist of fabric or leather and only accommodates one writing instrument?

In the thread, no satisfactory recommendation could be found that fulfils all criteria. Only the Andrée Putman case was suggested, which however is conceived for the 149 and would appear clearly too large for the 145. Other suitable alternatives without leather or fabric did not come to the participants' minds. The selection outside the common materials is thus strongly restricted.


How are simple inherited pen holders without brand marking to be classified historically and materially?

The pieces depicted are classical pen holders, that is, no fountain pens, and apparently brand pieces without identifiable manufacturer. A concrete determination or value statement is therefore hardly possible. The sentimental value as a memorial piece remains untouched.


Why does a Montblanc 146P suddenly write with significantly increased ink flow, possibly caused by frequent flights?

With frequent flights, the pressure change during climb and descent leads to more ink reaching the feed and partly the cap. A remedy is provided either by upright storage with the nib up or by carefully dabbing the lamellas under the nib with a tissue after the flight in order to absorb excess ink. If the strong ink flow remains, the nib can be slightly bent, which permanently increases the ink flow. The paper quality also plays an essential role for the flow behaviour.


Where are high-quality ballpoints, e.g. Limited Editions by Montblanc, best sold?

Suitable sales routes are the for-sale section of relevant collector forums, platforms like penexchange.de and eBay. Particularly recommendable are collectors' meet-ups and fountain-pen fairs, e.g. in Hamburg; dates can be found for example on cas1996.de. There, market prices and personal contacts can be especially well realised.


Is a Montblanc 149 nib whose slit clearly stands apart defective?

A wide nib slit is no necessary defect feature; the wider the slit, the higher the ink flow. From the factory the slit is, however, not so wide, so the piece described was presumably set by the previous owner for a saturated ink flow. Without macro shots of the tipping or a writing sample, the condition cannot be reliably judged. With an internet purchase without writing sample, it is therefore recommended in case of doubt to switch to pieces whose condition is clearly documented; regular 149s are anyway frequently available.


How does one fill an old Montblanc Masterpiece 642 with piston mechanism that has been unused for decades, and which ink is suitable?

With a writing instrument so long unused, ink residues almost always block the piston mechanism. It is urgently recommended to entrust the writing instrument to an expert who can properly make the mechanism workable. The plastic housing of these early Montblancs has lost plasticisers over the decades and is brittle, so it easily breaks with force application. Filling or disassembling oneself the fountain pen should therefore not be done.


How can one tell whether a Montblanc StarWalker with eight transverse grooves on the body auctioned on eBay is genuine?

The StarWalker fountain pen can above all be unambiguously distinguished from the fake by the characteristic original nib; comparison photos can be found on relevant collector sites. The discussion about the transverse grooves primarily concerned the ballpoint, on which original and counterfeit are harder to separate. Important: an original StarWalker fountain pen can, by design, only be filled with cartridges, not with a converter, since the rough grip section contains a special component inside. If a converter fits, it is a fake.


Which variants does the Montblanc Princesse Grace de Monaco Edition comprise?

The edition exists in two particularly limited variants: a version with only three examples and a variant with 29 pieces. Montblanc presents the edition on a specially set-up microsite and in an elaborate magazine that is available in the boutiques. The magazine contains large-format photos on Grace Kelly's career as well as on the further Limited Edition pieces. In the thread, no technical details beyond the existence of these variants and accompanying materials were named.


What did a Montblanc 144 cost in the early 50s?

In the year 1958, the shop price of the Montblanc 144 was 45 DM.


Is a Montblanc 149 with an unusually designed star on the cap (variant for the Arab market) an original, and is a nib change sensible?

Yes, this model is original. The only difference to the regular Meisterstück is the modified star that Montblanc has used for certain Arab markets. Such pieces are rare in Germany. A nib change is not recommended: it would be a pity to fit a modern nib into an older piece, and additionally such a repair is very expensive. The achieved sale price of around 225 euros counts as a bargain.


Should one post the cap on the back when writing with the fountain pen or rather not?

That is a matter of taste and depends strongly on the respective writing instrument. Small models like the 114 Mozart or a Kaweco Sport need the posted cap for reasonable balance, while a 146 Solitaire with posted cap quickly becomes too heavy and unwieldy. With middle Meisterstücks like the 146, many switch depending on the situation. Anyone wishing to avoid cap impressions and polish effort on the body writes basically without the cap. A general rule does not exist.


Why does a Sailor 1911 with ink-sac filling smear the fingers when writing, and what role does iron-gall ink play?

Possible causes are hairline cracks in the front part, a defective sac converter, damaged seals, an operating error or too deep a grip in which the fingers touch the nib corners. Iron-gall ink should be flushed out immediately, since it is unsuitable for many fountain pens and on drying can destroy the feed; in such cases only an exchange of the feed helps. Since with other writing instruments no problem occurs, grip errors are unlikely; the front part should be checked for visible hairline cracks.


Where is there a trustworthy private repair service for Montblanc writing instruments, e.g. for 146 models, and can one unscrew the nib oneself?

Recommended is the workshop of Horst (maxpens.de); an overview of repair options can also be found in the area Articles > Repair. A repair is only worthwhile with more valuable or still economically sensible writing instruments; with old 144s from the 50s, e.g., at most a cork change. Removing the nib is risky: usually the transition between grip section and body is heated, the grip section unscrewed and the feed together with the nib pressed out from behind. Too much heat deforms the celluloid, too little heat leads to breakage at the thread, which is why it is urgently advised against own attempts. An alternative is multi-day soaking and careful pulling out, however not without risk.


How should one best store a collection of writing instruments: in collection folders or in a wooden case?

Both storage forms are possible; in practice, experienced collectors combine various storage forms like boxes, folders, showcases and trays. Important is that the writing instruments are protected from mechanical damage and light. Hints and articles on proper storage can be found in the forum archives and in relevant specialist articles. Providers like penboard.de offer suitable boxes at moderate prices, although not always with a glass lid.


Are the depicted Montblanc ballpoints Ballpix 780, Carrera 570 multi-colour and Junior 690 originals?

All three depicted pieces are originals. Important for the classification: Montblanc has only been a pure luxury-goods manufacturer since 1991; before that, the entire spectrum from cheap school writing instrument to luxury product was made. Owing to today's perception as a luxury brand, even used simple models from that time often achieve more than their original new price.


Since when was the Montblanc 164 ballpoint produced in Bordeaux, does it still exist, and are the matching packaging and short serial number correct?

Bordeaux Montblancs have existed since the 1920s; the 164 Meisterstück ballpoint, however, has only been made since the mid-80s and with numerous detail changes. The Meisterstück Classique series in Bordeaux is still available, while the Meisterstück LeGrand in Bordeaux was discontinued two years ago and the Mozart in Bordeaux the previous year. The box in question is authentic but was likely used more than 20 years ago. A 164 without an engraved clip-ring number in this old box is plausible; pieces with a number are, on the other hand, younger than about five years. Some dealers voluntarily forgo stocking but accept orders.


What is the Montblanc Augmented Paper, how does it work and is it worth its price of 650 euros?

The Augmented Paper is a leather folder with a special pen in StarWalker style and Mozart ballpoint format that transfers handwritten notes from the pad to digital text with the help of a smartphone app. The underlying technology comes from Wacom, which makes long-term software maintenance likely; the comparable Wacom Bamboo Folio costs around 100 euros but offers no high-quality leather or premium writing instrument. Workmanship and handwriting recognition of the Montblanc variant are praised, provided one writes legibly. Negatively noted are the exclusively available A5 format, the limitation to single-sided writing and the binding to the Mozart ballpoint refill. Whether the price is justified depends on the value placed on the workmanship quality.


Are the small holes on the closure cap of a Montblanc 342 normal, or do they indicate a counterfeit?

The holes on the cap are normal, structurally intended air holes for pressure equalisation and must be present. Counterfeits of the 342 are unknown, since the model is price-wise unattractive for counterfeiters; imitations primarily concern fountain pens with overlay or coloured celluloid. For checking older writing instruments, a detailed comparison of the nib with further models of the same series as well as specialist literature like Collectible Stars is recommended.


Is an older lever filler with overlay an original Montblanc when a letter of Montblanc service from the twenties is available?

Despite the available letter, most likely no original is present. The letter from Montblanc is linguistically cautiously formulated ("writing-instrument type that we have made") and does not rule out that the concrete piece does not come from Montblanc. The overlay shows rather English production features; the clip could point to Pforzheim or an English manufacturer like Swan. Also the lever does not fit in this form to Montblanc production and would originally have been gilded. Additionally, the typical Montblanc star in the characteristic form is missing. Caution when buying such pieces is advised despite the accompanying letter.


Do Centrograph fountain pens come from the former Eastern Bloc, and can they be restored?

The manufacturer Centropen was based in Czechoslovakia; whether a concrete Centrograph piece actually comes from there cannot be reliably said without pictures. A restoration is generally not possible, since these fountain pens had an accordion tube as ink reservoir, which today is practically no longer procurable.


Is a Montblanc nib with imperial-eagle hallmark and inscription "NICHROM" on a Montblanc 236 original, and which nib size should the model have?

The NICHROM nib with imperial eagle is no Montblanc nib and does not belong in a 236. Correct for the 236 is a nib size 6, be it as a gold or steel nib; the model number does not encode the line width but price class, construction and housing/nib size. Line widths are exclusively indicated with capital letters (e.g. F, M, B). With the third series ("III MONTBLANC III"), instead of numbers the letters a, b, c in a triangle were used, with a, b, c corresponding to the nib sizes 2, 4, 6. A 234 would consequently have a smaller nib than a 236.


Can a supposedly old Montblanc fountain pen without model number and with an inconspicuous nib be identified based on photos?

The piece is a Montblanc SlimLine (SL) cartridge fountain pen, built between 1979 and 1982. It has a brass core with plastic surface, gilded trim and a gilded steel nib; the then shop price was about 49 DM. The SlimLine series was settled in the lower price segment, intended for school pupils and students, and lay below the Noblesse and the Meisterstück ranges. A rough model determination based on clear photos is mostly possible; with rare pieces a personal assessment is necessary.


How are the writing instruments of the brand Diplomat, specifically the Diplomat Excellence set, to be classified qualitatively?

Diplomat writing instruments are regarded as solid and well finished. The barrel is, compared to a Montblanc 146, somewhat thinner but lies roughly in the range of the Meisterstück Classique. Anyone preferring slim forms will be well served here. Detailed experience reports can be found in collector forums like penexchange.de.


Is a gilded Montblanc Meisterstück fountain pen with corn guilloche offered for 199 euros an original?

On the pictures, the fountain pen looks like an original, although the nib could come from an older model, since no hint of a central platinum intarsia is recognisable. An unambiguous bargain the price is not, especially since the piece shows an engraving; polishing out the engraving simultaneously removes the gilding at this point and makes an expensive re-gilding necessary. In addition, this model with corn guilloche is no longer being produced, which increases the appeal. The changeable auction behaviour (changed starting price, picture change, location change), however, gives cause for caution.


Can one ascertain from the serial number whether an offered Montblanc StarWalker Midnight Black ballpoint with inside stamp "Made in Germany" is an original?

A reliable authenticity check via the serial number is only possible by Montblanc itself, since only the manufacturer can interpret the coding. Especially with StarWalker ballpoints, the counterfeits are often very well made, which is why increased caution is advised. If identical serial numbers already turn up on the internet in connection with counterfeits, that is a clear warning sign; with the number mentioned that was not the case, which is at least not a bad sign.


How does one recognise counterfeits of the Montblanc Lalique 4810 Limited fountain pen stand, which partly turn up without obvious features?

Recognisable are counterfeits, among other things, by a black star on the packaging as well as by the inferior packaging quality overall. There have, however, also been very well-made fakes without these obvious hints sold, e.g. by an American provider who earned around 160 US dollars per stand. Even experienced collectors have already fallen for well-made fakes like the Greta Garbo. Therefore: always compare carefully and inform oneself thoroughly before purchase.


Is a Montblanc Rouge et Noir fountain pen without a serial number on the clip ring despite the presence of Pix genuine?

Yes, the predecessor variants Noir et Noir and Rouge et Noir were delivered before the Bohème series without an identification number in the clip ring. The missing serial number is therefore no indication of a counterfeit. The writing instrument is therefore to be regarded as original.


Which hard-to-obtain Limited Editions were most recently in stock in the Munich and Düsseldorf boutiques?

In the Munich boutique, among others, the Greta Garbo Limited 100 as well as the Golden Dragon 2000 were available, plus numerous Patrons of the Arts and Writers Editions. In the new Düsseldorf boutique, e.g., I Love NY, Gutenberg, Musashi, Russian Flag, Montblanc 100 rose gold, Bohème 100s and 75s, 144s and 117s, Juilliard Centennial Celebration as well as various 888s and 4810 editions, supplemented by the Golden Dragon were found. The Düsseldorf boutique is additionally regarded as particularly impressively designed, with a several-metre-long, illuminated art object of the Montblanc summit.


What consequences does the sale of the shops have for the future business area of the provider?

In future, exclusively writing instruments of limited editions of various manufacturers from earlier years will be offered; new goods will no longer be carried. The occupation with historical Montblancs will continue to be pursued. In the forum thread, no substantial further factual information beyond this business announcement was given.


How can two inherited, supposedly original Montblanc writing instruments (Karajan ballpoint) be verified based on poor photos?

The pieces depicted are presumably Montblanc Donation ballpoints of the Karajan series. Owing to the dark, unsharp photos, a reliable authenticity confirmation is not possible, since well-made counterfeits are known. A typical indication of fakes is a thinly stamped clip pin instead of a massive original clip; therefore a detail shot of the back of the clip is recommended. Without better pictures, the final judgement remains open.


How is the hair-fine nib slit produced in Montblanc nib manufacture?

The nib slit arises through hair-thin parting discs with which the nib is cut in a fine-mechanical step. This information comes from a factory-inspection report in the Fountainpen newsletter No. 5, which contains details on nib manufacture at Montblanc.


Which ID number and which then retail price did the Montblanc Writers Edition 2001 Charles Dickens have?

The Charles Dickens from the Writers Edition 2001 cost 620 euros at market introduction. Montblanc assigns to every writing instrument of a Writers Edition its own ID number, which is found, among other places, on the outer packaging; alongside, the goods number (model number) exists, which marks the entire series and on the Dickens reads M 28710. The ID numbers additionally distinguish by nib width: on the Dickens, the F nib bears the number 2480 (with special packaging Autograph 2485), the M nib 2481 (or 2486) and the B nib 2482 (or 2487). The ballpoint has the ID number 2483 (or 2452), the complete three-set 2484 (or 2488 with nib M). This differentiation makes sense above all with orders, because it avoids confusion between the nib widths and packaging variants.


Which model could the unknown fountain pen be?

Based on the available hints, the pen was estimated as a Montblanc 34 or a 32. The exact assignment depends above all on the length of the fountain pen, since these two models differ from each other in dimensions. An unambiguous identification is only possible with concrete dimensions.


Which fountain pen in the range around 150 euros is suitable for daily, long writing in training, and how does one choose between models with steel or gold nib?

Today's fountain pens from the middle price segment technically all write at a comparably high level, which is why the decision strongly depends on subjective factors like ink flow, nib width, feel and look. Manufacturers like Lamy, Pelikan and Graf von Faber-Castell offer very good workmanship as well as reliable service. It is recommended to try out the models oneself before purchase and to bring one's own everyday paper in order to check the ink flow and nib width realistically. Ultimately, gut feeling decides, since with none of these models can one go significantly wrong.


What can one do if a Pelikan fountain pen has too strong an ink flow and smears the paper?

Frequently the problem lies in the ink used, since some types dry very slowly and tend to smearing; a switch to another ink, e.g. Montblanc or Jansen, can here provide significant remedy. Alongside, dried ink residues are a typical cause that glue up the feed and produce an irregular flow. A thorough flushing of the fountain pen with distilled water helps in many cases. On newer Pelikan models, the nib together with feed can be unscrewed and soaked overnight in a water glass, by which stubborn deposits are loosened.


Has the Montblanc Bohème ever existed as a gilded variant with a black onyx stone?

The Montblanc Bohème actually exists with a black stone on the clip; this is even one of the most-sold variants of the series, which formerly bore the name Rouge & Noir. The trim consists, however, not of white gold but is platinum-plated; a gilding with white gold Montblanc has never offered on the Bohème. The pieces described in the offer are most likely genuine; only the seller's material description is misleading. For a final judgement, meaningful photos are helpful.


What does the Montblanc Writers Edition William Faulkner look like, and is the early release date correct?

The Faulkner is a piston filler whose body and cap consist predominantly of transversely ribbed silver, presumably platinum-plated, similar to the cap of the StarWalker Doué. The barrel end with the piston mechanism as well as the upper cap end are made of brownish-shimmering precious resin. The nib is rhodium-plated and shows a gold-coloured engraving with clouds and a plane flying below them. The description was confirmed in the forum as fitting, although the early delivery date was surprising.


How can a stuck refill be removed from a 20-year-old Montblanc Solitaire 925 Faden ballpoint?

With stuck refills, it is recommended to open the ballpoint and to push from the front through the tip against the old refill with a new refill in order to carefully push it out backwards. This method generally works reliably and avoids damage to the mechanism.


Which Montblanc model is behind the cap-ring marking 1255 or 1266 in sterling silver with longitudinal guilloche?

It is presumably the Montblanc 1266, a Meisterstück piston filler with sterling-silver thread guilloche, which was made between 1971 and 1976 in small numbers. It has a rhodium-plated 18-carat gold nib. Early examples had a massive feed with a metal-mounted ventilation hole, later ones a flatter, more reliable feed. Due to the rarity, the collector value in flawless condition lies up to 1000 euros. In the standard work Collectible Stars, this model is not listed.


How is one to deal with professional sellers who auction obvious counterfeits of old Montblanc writing instruments and do not react to hints?

Even experienced professional sellers occasionally offer counterfeits, e.g. from a normal 136 and celluloid assembled supposed rarities that can achieve high prices in the high four-digit range. Especially with old writing instruments, counterfeits are often so well made that even collectors do not recognise them at first glance. If a seller is pointed to a counterfeit and does not react or only refers to the previous owner, this behaviour is to be classified as bordering on fraud and damages his credibility. Buyers should exercise particular caution with such providers and have offers in case of doubt checked by experienced collectors.


Where can one buy Montblanc Limited Editions as a gift, and what is the difference between a Limited Edition and a Special Edition?

Current Limited Editions are available at every Montblanc dealer as well as directly in the Montblanc shop; older Limited Editions are found above all on eBay or at specialised collector sites like penboard.de or Fritz Schimpf. On the mentioned site liebl.exklusives-schreiben.de, on the other hand, no Limited Editions but normal editions and Special Editions were carried. The decisive difference: with Limited Editions the quantity is limited from the start, while Special Editions are only produced in a certain period but in unlimited quantity. To the Special Editions belong, e.g., the UNICEF editions, Brahms or Lennon. Which piece fits well into a collection can only be judged when the collector's holdings are known.


Are there concrete hints of a Montblanc Limited Edition on Goethe?

Concrete and confirmed hints of a Goethe edition did not exist at the time of the discussion; even enquiries at Montblanc boutiques remained without result. Such an edition is among collectors regarded as an obvious idea, e.g. within the framework of the Writers Edition, but has so far not been announced. Anyone wishing to follow current rumours on coming Limited Editions finds these, by experience, early in the forum of fountainpennetwork.com.


Are there at Montblanc counterfeits with plastic housings or are the counterfeits restricted to lacquered metal housings?

Montblanc counterfeits with resin or plastic housings have existed for some time, even if lacquered metal housings are more frequently encountered. A known example is the counterfeit of the Limited Edition Kafka, which also consists of resin. With the counterfeit of the Greta Garbo, even a new, significantly improved nib variant was discovered that comes very close to the original. The quality of the imitations thus continuously rises also in the area of materials and nibs, which makes identification for laypersons increasingly difficult.


From what period does a green-marbled Montblanc Meisterstück with the patent number DRP 508058 and the marking 30 at the barrel end come?

It is the Meisterstück Stylo number 30, made between 1930/31 and 1934; the barrel number 30 refers to the then retail price of 30 Reichsmark. From the factory the model was originally not a fountain pen with nib but a push filler with stylo tip, to which the patent number mentioned unambiguously points. Often the black front part with the stylo tip was subsequently exchanged for a grip section with nib. On the green-marbled celluloid housings, discolourations as well as material shrinkages additionally often occur.


Can one judge from unsharp photos whether a Montblanc 144 is genuine or a counterfeit, and can converters from other manufacturers fit?

A reliable authenticity check is not possible without sharp, detail-rich photos; especially the imprints on the nib must be clearly recognisable. A clear warning sign in the present judgement was a converter that unambiguously did not come from Montblanc. Converters of other makes can mechanically fit but do not speak for an original set. Imprints like Germany on the clip alone do not deliver authenticity proof.


Is the Montblanc Soulmakers 100 Anniversary Bohème offered on eBay a counterfeit?

The writing instrument is genuine; it is the officially issued Bohème 1906 Edition for the 100-year company jubilee of Montblanc. Further information and illustrations can be found at fountainpen.de on the page on the Anniversary 100 Bohème 1906. The model is actually comparatively little known, which can cause uncertainty in sales.


How can a damaged Montblanc Le Grand ballpoint with a hole in the star or a scratched 146 be repaired?

Repairs on Montblanc writing instruments are basically carried out only directly by the manufacturer; a spare-parts sale to end customers does not take place. The repair prices are, compared to other manufacturers, however moderate. Sensible is a call to Montblanc customer service in order to obtain a cost estimate in advance. The writing instrument can then either be sent in directly or given via a specialist retailer for repair, with the latter possibly entailing additional costs.


Where can one obtain the collector's book The List on Montblanc writing instruments, and how is its quality to be assessed?

The book is as a reference work, despite some weaknesses, unique; criticised, however, are the partly disproportionate illustrations and the mediocre picture quality, which can give laypersons a wrong impression of the writing instruments; an improved new edition is planned but temporally still open. Source is mostly Regina Martini, who offers the book regularly in her eBay auctions. Most recently the price was around 12.50 euros plus postage. Alternatively, Mrs Martini can also be enquired about directly.


Is a used Montblanc Meisterstück 164P for 129 euros via a classified ads platform a good purchase?

Whether the price is reasonable depends decisively on the actual condition and the completeness (original box, service guide). The provider named is known from eBay and has there already sold numerous allegedly near-new 164Ps, which gives cause for caution; queries about the origin of the pieces were not reliably answered. An authenticity check after purchase is therefore urgently recommended. Basically: with doubtful sources, one should keep one's hands off the deal, provided the authenticity and origin are not clarified beyond doubt.


What factual information was given on the C.A.S. collectors' get-together on 25 February 2007 in Dortmund?

The C.A.S. collectors' get-together took place on Sunday, 25 February 2007, from 14:00. The venue was the restaurant Zum Franziskaner, Düsseldorfer Str. 21, 44143 Dortmund (telephone 0231/586 21 18). In the restaurant, the possibility existed to take a lunch at one's own expense, although the kitchen was closed between 15:00 and 17:00. In total, eleven collectors took part.


What background and sources are there on the mentioned online video about fountain pens?

The video stands in connection with an article from the customer magazine of Deutsche Bank in the November issue, in which investment possibilities in the area of writing instruments are reported. Mentioned in it is also the work of the C.A.S.; the magazine used photos made available by the C.A.S. The corresponding report can be read as a PDF on pages 34 to 37 of the corresponding issue.


Which reputable sources for high-quality Montblanc pens as a birthday gift are there on the internet?

Recommendable online sources for Montblanc writing instruments are the official Montblanc website with direct ordering possibility as well as the dealers fuellhalter.de, onlinehandel-AS.de and especially missing-pen.de from Rolf Thiel. The latter is classified as very recommendable. On the mentioned site liebl.exklusives-schreiben.de, no own experiences were available, so no evaluation could be given on it.


How does one correctly reply in the forum to a post, so that the reply is properly assigned to the original entry?

In order for a reply to be correctly sorted under the corresponding post, the reply button must be used, which stands directly under the respective post. There, at the bottom right, are the buttons Reply and Quote. If, instead, a button above the post is used, the reply can be sorted incorrectly.


Where can information be found on sales periods and original prices of Montblanc writing instruments from 1980 onwards like Traveller, Noblesse, Slim Line or Carrera?

The standard work Collectible Stars by Stefan Wallrafen covers writing instruments only up to 1979 and therefore offers no complete data for the desired models of the 1980s; some devices are additionally missing there entirely. A suitable point of contact for historical catalogues and supplementary information is Stefan Wallrafen himself, who has(d) extensive material but has in recent years given up holdings. Even if some models were produced longer than stated, the production periods named in the book are reliable for most devices. Original dealer catalogues from the period 1980 to 1985 are the most reliable source for exact sales periods and prices.


How high is the approximate value of a Montblanc Year of the Golden Dragon to be estimated?

Two different Year of the Golden Dragon exist: an edition of 2000 pieces as well as an edition of 888 pieces (among others in Meissen porcelain); additionally there are Special Limited Editions. The launch price of the 2000 edition was between about 2400 and 2800 euros. The variant with Meissen porcelain had a list price of around 3850 euros. As a utility pen, the model is only restrictedly suitable because of the very massive clip; as a collector's piece, however, attractive.


Where can one cheaply obtain original refills for the Montblanc Meisterstück Classique Line?

Outside eBay, bargains on original refills are hardly to be found, since mail-order dealers with such low-value articles often do not allow the minimum order value and prices online hardly differ from specialist trade. On eBay, 10-packs are occasionally offered; here, however, caution is in order, since refills are now also being counterfeited. Anyone wanting to be safe therefore buys best from the authorised specialist retailer or from Montblanc itself.