How does one classify an old Montblanc Safety pen from family possession with octagonal form, and what is it worth?

The piece described is an octagonal Montblanc Safety No. 2 with OB nib; the engraving 20B refers to the nib width OB. The fountain pen is very similarly to be classified as the documented Astoria No. 02 Octagonal Safety Filler. Cracks basically reduce the market value significantly but are emotionally hardly relevant for family heirlooms. Comparable octagonal Safetys are regularly traded on eBay and lie in market value significantly above that of a damaged Meisterstück 14, which is economically classified rather as a parts donor.


Is a research enquiry of the marketing chair of TU Berlin on the topic of communities serious, and should one participate?

The enquiry counts, after telephone consultation with the responsible person, as serious and is therefore recommended for participation, presumably within the framework of a diploma thesis. Universities are with scientific studies dependent on volunteers outside the student circle. The survey is anonymous, and for scientific surveys the guidelines of the ADM e.V. apply, according to which data may only be further processed anonymously and no conclusions about individuals are permissible. Sensitive questions, e.g. on salary, can be skipped without consequences.


How can one with an eBay purchase of a Montblanc 146 with an unusual nib constellation have the authenticity checked?

The model described is a real Montblanc 146 with a barrel as was fitted until into the 1980s. The deviating nib indicates that it was exchanged over time, e.g. in favour of another nib width. A missing or strokeless ink window combined with a bicolour nib is therefore no necessary counterfeit feature. Anyone nevertheless wanting a final assessment can turn to a reputable vintage specialist retailer or an experienced collector.


How can a 30-35 year old Parker set consisting of ballpoint and fountain pen be identified?

The set described is a Parker Classic ballpoint and a Parker 75 fountain pen, which despite similar guilloche embossing come from two different model series and thus do not form a matching set. The Parker 75 was produced from 1964 for over 30 years and belongs to the most frequent Parker writing instruments; the Parker Classic has been made since the early 1970s and partly until today. An exact age can hardly be determined from general pictures, but a range of 30 to 35 years is quite plausible. The housings are only gilded and not of solid gold.


Why was forum registration temporarily switched to manual approval?

Owing to a SPAM wave with temporarily 20 to 50 new registrations per hour, the registration was supplemented so that not only an email confirmation but additionally manual approval by the webmaster is necessary. Reading without registration remains possible; only posting requires the check. With very high registration volume (in an example about 300 registrations per day), it can happen that regular registrations are also accidentally rejected; in such cases one should turn by email to the webmaster. The measure is temporarily set up and will be loosened again as soon as the spam pressure subsides.


How can a silver Montblanc ballpoint for the 75-year anniversary with mother-of-pearl star, brilliant and serial number be classified?

The writing instrument described is the Classique Rollerball Solitaire 163 in sterling silver with vermeil thread guilloche and rose-gold trim from the Limited 1924 Edition for the 75-year anniversary. The authenticity can be well checked by comparison with the documented features on relevant collector sites. Further information on this edition can be found on fountainpen.de under the Anniversary Limited Editions. From disreputable auctions in which pictures of real pieces are misused for other types of models, caution is in order.


Is the high price for the collector's book by Jens Rösler on the Montblanc Diary and Collectors Guide justified?

The price for the book rises since years approximately half-yearly by around 50 euros, since the work is out of print and only available in limited numbers. It counts among collectors as a standard reference and nearly indispensable reference for pre-war Montblanc writing instruments. Owing to supply and demand, prices around 200 euros are by now seen as appropriate. Anyone who already owns a copy is well served; everyone else should regard the acquisition as long-term sensible.


How can a layperson check whether a Montblanc 149 acquired on eBay is genuine?

Based on clear detail photos, the authenticity of a 149 can generally be reliably judged. In the specific case it is an original from the 1980s and not the current model. Older examples are thus not automatically suspicious but can quite well be authentic. With uncertainty, it is recommended to post additional close-ups and compare them with reference pictures.


Is it normal that in the barrel of a Montblanc StarWalker Doué a second cartridge rattles?

With most cartridge fountain pens it is usual that a reserve cartridge is carried as ink supply in the barrel; exceptions at Montblanc are only the Bohème series as well as the Mozart format. On the StarWalker the second cartridge should however not rattle; an enquiry at Montblanc in Hamburg confirmed that this is no standard behaviour. Anyone wishing to avoid the effect can simply remove the reserve cartridge. If the rattling occurs permanently, the writing instrument should be complained about at the specialist retailer.


Can the ID number on an inherited Montblanc fountain pen be re-registered to the new owner?

The number on a Montblanc writing instrument is a pure serial number that has no reference to the owner. Writing instruments are not registered to persons; a rewriting is therefore neither necessary nor possible. From the number, at most production-related data can be derived; the exact meaning only Montblanc knows. The inherited pen can be used without further formalities.


Does an allegedly deviating mechanism justify a premium for a Montblanc 342 from 1950 offered as a prototype?

The designation prototype is, with a 342 of usual look, generally not justified; it is mostly a normal series example. Writing instruments with an untypical component mix are at Montblanc no rarity, especially from wartime, and do not lead to a value increase. On the contrary, a deviating mechanism rather indicates a tinkered piece and reduces the value. High price demands of individual sellers say nothing about the real market value but bet on uninformed buyers.


Can one judge from photos whether a used-bought Montblanc 145 Chopin is genuine?

On the available shots, no features are recognisable that would indicate a counterfeit, so the pen is most likely an original. Since complete sets together with original packaging are also being counterfeited, for reliable judgement preferably more than one detail photo should be presented. Ink flow and writing behaviour are with a well-preserved original generally flawless. In case of doubt, the direct comparison of the nib with documented features of real pieces is worthwhile.


Which model is an old Montblanc rollerball from the 1980s with unclear assignment to Noblesse or Slimline?

The writing instrument depicted is the Montblanc Quickpen of stainless steel, which was produced between 1979 and 1986. The retail price was depending on year between 14.50 and 19.50 DM. The Quickpen was delivered in an about DIN A5 sized silvery cardboard packaging with clear-plastic slider and three refills, one rollerball, one fineliner and one felt-tip refill. It is not identical with the models Noblesse or Slimline.


Does the most recently observed price decline of Montblanc Meisterstücks from the 1950s explain itself through a trend?

The prices on the collector market for vintage Meisterstücks fluctuate considerably and can only restrictedly be traced to individual trends. By way of example, a 139 brought about a year ago around 4500 USD, while current prices lie significantly lower; even a 149 with silver rings lost significantly in value within a short time. The collector market behaves in this respect similarly to the stock market, with partly not understandable up and down movements. Trend statements should therefore be regarded with caution.


Can piston converters, e.g. from Rotring, be used in the Montblanc StarWalker?

Even if foreign piston converters like the one from Rotring fit mechanically into the StarWalker, their use should be avoided. Montblanc has deliberately excluded the use of converters on this model, because ink residues that remain when dipping into the ink bottle in the resin grip section cannot be completely removed. The consequence are inevitably contaminations in the cap and on the fingers. Cartridges are therefore on the StarWalker the only sensible filling method.


How can an older Montblanc fountain pen without platinum intarsia be identified and checked for authenticity?

The piece depicted is an original, namely a Meisterstück 144 Classique from older production that does not yet show platinum intarsia on the star. Such models appear at first glance different than the current versions but are authentic writing instruments. Comparative detail shots from collector sites and earlier forum posts help with unambiguous assignment. The 144 Classique counts as a very beautiful and popular fountain pen.


Did the old Pelikan models Ibis and Rappen have flexible or rather stiff nibs?

With the nibs of the old Pelikan Ibis and Rappen models there is no uniform picture; depending on the example, they can turn out flexible or rather stiff. A flat-rate statement is therefore not possible. For more detailed assessments, an enquiry in a specialised Pelikan forum is recommended. Hints like the nib size and the inscription 585K Gold help with model assignment; among the typical construction count individual narrow cap rings, a green ink window and hard rubber as material.


Where can one find in the USA resellers or second-hand shops for older Montblanc writing instruments before 1960?

Concrete German-language tips on sources in Miami, New York, Las Vegas or Los Angeles are hardly available. For the search for US dealers, flea markets and second-hand addresses, an enquiry in the English-language forum fountainpennetwork.com is recommended. There, posting is however restricted in some areas and only possible from a certain minimum number of contributions. Anyone not yet having a sufficient posting count can first introduce themselves in the Introductions area and there include the question.


What information can be found on the fountain-pen brand Wende?

Wende fountain pens existed that were filled by means of a push button from behind via a pipette rubber sac. The size corresponded roughly to a Montblanc 146; the material was presumably brown Bakelite, and the nib consisted of gold. On the cap, USA was engraved, without thereby an unambiguous origin being secured. The filling system was at the time even in stationery shops little known.


How is the new Pelikan Limited Edition Temple of Artemis from the 7 Wonders range to be assessed in design terms?

The edition counts overall as interestingly designed, although the striking gold capital is felt to be too large and dominating. Positive to highlight is that Pelikan has given the edition its own form and not again used the indeed beautiful but widespread Souverän form as base. The design of the Pelikan LEs of recent years is otherwise partly felt to require getting used to. Concrete price information is not given in the thread.


Is the Meisterstück 149 of the Unicef Edition by Jahn or Putman still available in trade, and at what price?

A dealer in Traunstein most recently offered the Unicef edition for around 688 euros. Concrete further sources are not named. Since it is a Limited Edition, availability and price depend on the respective provider. An enquiry to the specialist retailer or to Montblanc itself is recommended for current information.


Is a silver-plated cassette with high-fine pocket pencils No. 1 by Graf von Faber-Castell still available and which price is reasonable?

The silver-plated cassettes are currently only offered with normal pencils, no longer with the fine pocket pencils. The collector value of the empty box itself is around 40 euros; individual boxes without pencils are now and then traded on eBay. Compared to the former shop price, a purchase at the current market price generally represents an advantage. The box hardly has a value-increasing effect on the contained pencils; the price counts as appropriate.


How high was the original shop price of the Montblanc J.S. Bach fountain pen?

According to the Compendium of limited editions issued by Montblanc, the shop price of the J.S. Bach fountain pen was 400 euros. Further price-relevant information was not mentioned in the thread. It is a Limited Edition from the Patron of Arts or Donation range, which is documented in specialised collector sources. Current market prices can deviate from this.


Do all pencils of the Montblanc Writers Edition have the same lead thickness and is the lead interchangeable?

Most pencils from the Writers Edition are equipped with a lead thickness of 0.7 mm. There are, however, exceptions, e.g. the Oscar Wilde mechanical pencil with a lead of 0.9 mm. A tolerance for deviating lead thicknesses is not provided on these writing instruments; a switch to thinner or thicker leads is therefore not possible. Before buying replacement leads, the respective model should be checked.


Can current nibs be fitted to a Pelikan M250 from 1991 instead of the existing BB nib?

Whether current Pelikan nibs fit a M250 from the build year 1991 cannot flat-rate be answered, since construction details can vary over the years. For reliable information, contact with a designated Pelikan expert, e.g. via the website rüttinger-web.de, is recommended. Alternatively, the question can be asked in a specialised Pelikan forum. Both routes experience-shows lead to competent answers on nib compatibility.


Is a Montblanc pen auctioned for 120 euros an original or a plagiarism?

The piece depicted is a real Meisterstück 145, which at this price counts as very cheaply acquired. The nib quality is still the clearest authenticity feature, since counterfeiters here still lag behind the original, even if the plagiarisms overall are getting better and better. The material is actually plastic or plexiglass, which Montblanc markets under the term precious resin. On any cracks in the cap, attention should nevertheless be paid to safety so as not to reduce the value.


Is a Montblanc 121 with 750 gold nib and amber-coloured viewing window from the 1960s genuine and what value does it have?

The Montblanc Meisterstück 121 was produced from 1970 to 1973/74 with thick feed and from 1974 to 1979 with flat feed; a dating to the 1960s therefore does not quite fit. It is an original and not a counterfeit; no plagiarisms of this model are known. The collector value is rather low, because the model is still too young for a pronounced collector demand. As a reliable daily writer, the 121 is, however, still usable.


What value does a Montblanc Charles Dickens 3-set have whose pen bears a different serial number than the other parts?

Complete Charles Dickens sets with identical serial numbers are currently traded on eBay for about 1000 euros, occasionally also for 1200 to 1300 euros. Boutiques can generally not call up or offer this market price. Sets with deviating serial numbers tend to be given a value discount; an exact quantification of the loss is, however, difficult possible. Before purchase, comparison with current auction offers is worthwhile as orientation aid.


Where can current sale prices and list prices of a Montblanc collection be ascertained, e.g. for household contents insurance?

Official price lists are rarely to be found on the internet, since Montblanc deliberately does not create global price transparency, and prices vary by country. As reference points, the price list of 2010 with a percentage surcharge serves as well as the online shops of large dealers like Schacht-Westerich or Montblanc's own online shop. With Limited Editions, Montblanc avoids the publication of shop prices, since these rise in the boutiques over time; hints can be partly found in old Creations of Passion brochures. Anyone taking shop prices as evaluation basis lies generally on the safe side, because the market value of most Writers Editions does not exceed this price; with very rare pieces, auction prices achieved in the past, e.g. from Bonhams, are helpful.


Is a leather case offered at an auction from older production a real Montblanc case?

The leather case shown is a real Montblanc product from the 1970s or 1980s. The workmanship, however, is comparatively plain and simple and not comparable to current Montblanc leather cases. Anyone valuing the model above all for visual reasons can acquire it without authenticity concerns. An expectation of today's quality level is however inappropriate.


Does the plastic bag in the original packaging of a Limited Edition influence the collector value?

The plastic bag in the original packaging has no significant influence on the value of a writing instrument and can be disposed of without hesitation. Anyone valuing the appearance can have the packaging re-sealed by Montblanc free of charge within half a year after acquisition. On eBay, sealed original packagings tend to achieve somewhat higher prices. Even at renowned auction houses like Bonhams in Los Angeles, only previously checked writing instruments are auctioned.


What information is available on the Montblanc Solitaire Facets Edition and in which sizes is it available?

The edition is officially called Meisterstück Solitaire Platinum-Plated Facet, whose body and cap are platinum-plated and show a broad cubic structure. First presented was a 146 with M nib under the number 38237; according to information from Montblanc the model was additionally offered in size 144. By now the range is available as LeGrand and Classique fountain pen as well as ballpoint, rollerball and pencil. The look with the cubic surface structure is a matter of taste and is controversially perceived.


Is the Montblanc Solitaire Platinum Plated Facet 8 with B nib suitable as a study companion, and is the slim variant the right choice?

For intensive writing in studies, the resin grip area of the Montblanc fountain pens speaks, since models with a metal grip can slip more easily from the hand during longer exams. The nib strength should fit the size of the handwriting; a B nib is rather for large, an F or M nib for smaller handwritings. With the Solitaire model, weight and look of the slimmer variant often decide in favour of this construction. Advantageous is additionally that the nib can be exchanged at the specialist retailer free of charge if the chosen strength does not convince during writing.


From what production time does a Montblanc ballpoint 77 acquired on eBay come and is it genuine?

The Montblanc 77 is an original and was produced according to the standard work Collectible Stars between 1960 and 1961. It is thus an authentic vintage writing instrument and not a counterfeit. Further authenticity features can be traced based on the illustrations documented there.


How are the current gift packagings and warranty booklets of the Montblanc models 146 and 146P to be classified, and are they internationally uniform?

The packaging type depicted has been used as standard for Montblanc writing instruments including the classic Meisterstück for about a year, however not exclusively for the 146P. These standard gift packagings are delivered by Montblanc free of charge to authorised dealers and are filled exclusively by specialist trade with the writing instrument and warranty booklet; an official sale of the empty packagings does not take place. Solitaire and higher-quality models receive deviating, independent gift packagings. From China, counterfeits of these packagings are by now also in circulation, which complicates the visual authenticity check additionally.


Which converters fit into an older fountain pen for which the current Montblanc converters with thread do not grip?

Older models do not need a converter with thread like the variants today common at Montblanc; the modern converters therefore only restrictedly fit. Instead, converters without thread, e.g. from Waterman or Pelikan, can be used without problem. Before purchase, comparison of the fastening type is recommended, since the thread on vintage fountain pens does not fit. About the exact price of the individual converters, no information is given in the thread.


What significance does the 2006 stamp block with writing instruments by Cleo Skribent as motif have?

Nowadays stamps can also be created by private providers with self-chosen motifs, so writing instruments by Cleo Skribent as motif are no peculiarity of the state post. Such stamps are above all suitable as individual promotional gifts for companies. In the postal sector, in recent years several private service providers like Turbo P.O.S.T., PIN AG and Westdeutscher Post Service have come on the market with their own stamps. The actual collecting appeal of such stamp editions is manageable.


Do the Montblanc Greta Garbo fountain pens bear a serial number, and if so, at what place?

Of Montblanc three versions of the Greta Garbo models exist: two limited editions with 100 or 1905 pieces as well as the unlimited model with an ivory-coloured cap and matching ballpoint. The limited pieces always bear their individual edition number including the total edition as engraving. On the unlimited models, only a very small identification number, only legible with a magnifier, is located in the clip ring. A classical serial number as on old Montblanc writing instruments no longer exists on today's models.


From what time does the dark-green Montblanc lever ballpoint with the designation 380 Germany come?

The Montblanc ballpoint 380 was, according to Collectible Stars, in total produced from 1971 to 1979, with three different versions existing. The dark-green variant was only made between 1971 and 1975 and is depicted on page 73 of the standard work. Thus the pen can be relatively precisely classified temporally. For an unambiguous assignment to the respective variant, a sharp photo of the writing instrument is helpful.


Does Montblanc actually produce unusual products like knives and are such pieces unrestrictedly worth collecting?

Such unusual products are generally not made by Montblanc itself but by commissioned third-party firms that either produce exclusively for Montblanc or only apply name and logo. Therefore, these pieces do not have a special manufacture-related value, since they did not arise in the Montblanc manufacture. A certain collector value they nevertheless retain, because they officially belong to the brand world. Whether a particular concrete piece, e.g. from an auction, is original should be checked case by case.


Which ink and cleaning method are to be recommended for a Montblanc Bohème, and how does it stand with disassembled body sleeves?

Black inks count across manufacturers as problematic and can on the Bohème more frequently lead to difficulties; a switch to blue-black or blue is recommended. With persistent problems, the visit to the specialist retailer is sensible, since an on-site check helps most. For cleaning the Bohème, separate instructions can be found in the forum; decisive is that no water reaches the mechanism. Anyone with questions about components like the front body sleeve or wishing to delve deeper into the topic can additionally use a factory visit or a local collectors' table.


Is it a defect if the screwed-on cap of the Montblanc 146P shows some play at the lower edge?

The lateral play at the lower cap edge described is structurally caused and represents no defect, provided the cap overall sits firmly on the barrel. It lies within the usual production tolerance and is deliberately produced by a softer inner cap so the cap edge leaves no marks on the barrel when posting and removing. Decisive for the flawless function is that the fountain pen does not dry out with the cap screwed on and writes immediately when writing. Despite the play, on screw threads occasional scratches on the barrel can arise, which technically cannot be completely avoided.


How can a Montblanc button filler without star emblem on the cap and without nib inscription be classified?

The single cap ring points to the inexpensive 3xx series, whose star is merely engraved into the cap top. The form speaks for a production period from the 1930s. Nib and possibly feed could have been exchanged in between, and whether cap and barrel belong together is not unambiguously to be clarified without inspection. Unlike the designation suggests, the body does not consist of plastic, since plastics only became common in writing instruments in the 1950s.


Is there a German dealer that distributes current Conklin fountain pens?

A specifically Conklin-specialised German dealer is not known, which is why the brand is frequently sourced via American providers. At martiniauctions.com, Conklin writing instruments are occasionally offered. Alongside, full-range providers like Albrecht Schroeder carry a broad brand spectrum from Aurora to Yard-O-Led; a telephone enquiry or contact via the web form can be worthwhile. A systematic source for current Conklin models in Germany, however, is missing.


Of which sub-series does the Montblanc Precious Dragon 8 series consist?

The Precious Dragon 8 series comprises four sub-series that appeared under the designations Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald and Diamond. The individual pieces count among collectors as interesting variations of the Dragon series. Concrete price information or further technical details are not named in the thread. For illustration, the thread refers to pages of Airline International with illustrations of all four sub-series.


How reliable is an eBay seller for a Montblanc StarWalker Special Edition Ballpoint Pen 38302 and are there counterfeits?

Description, instruction and positive ratings as well as a stated phone number and a more than two-year-long membership at eBay speak for a reputable handling. The seller has additionally in the past already sold Montblanc articles with positive ratings. Based on the photos, the offered writing instrument appears authentic. For additional safeguarding, payment via PayPal is recommended, since buyer protection thereby applies.


How is the quality of current counterfeits of Montblanc vintage rollerballs to be assessed?

The quality of the counterfeits is significantly improving, so current vintage-rollerball plagiarisms are visually no longer easy to expose. Striking are partly contradictory detail engravings, e.g. inscriptions like Hemingway on a cap that does not fit the model designation. Generally, as a rollerball there are anyway no comparable originals from the corresponding vintage range. Anyone valuing the characteristic tie clip finds as a legitimate alternative e.g. the Astoria models, which also show such a clip.


How can a disintegrating casein star on a Montblanc push filler of size 6 from the 1930s be conserved or replaced?

With a disintegrating casein star, in the short term a covering with cold enamel helps in order to stop further decay. The self-manufacture of casein as a replacement material is occasionally discussed; corresponding recipes exist; their practical suitability, however, is unclear and would have to be tried out case by case. For a professional restoration, contact with specialised restorers like maxpens.de is recommended. A pure polish, as is usual with intact stars, should be avoided on damaged casein stars.


Is a Meisterstück 146 auctioned on eBay with the engraving Montblanc Meisterstück No. 146 genuine?

The writing instrument depicted is one hundred percent genuine and comes from the 1980s. The engraving Montblanc Meisterstück No. 146 is typical of this production phase and therefore differs in size and form from later models like the Traveller of 2001. The condition is additionally described as very good, the purchase price as appropriate. There is thus no suspicion of counterfeit.


How can a Mont-Blanc fountain pen found in an old garage be classified and is a sale worthwhile?

The piece is likely a Mont Blanc 17.5 with push-button mechanism from the 1930s, which is far too good to throw away. Before a sale, it is recommended to observe the price development of similar writing instruments over some weeks on eBay in order to gain a realistic classification. There is no hurry; keeping it or a later, well-prepared sale are more sensible than a hasty disposal. For a value statement, it is additionally helpful to obtain further information on the model and its preservation condition.


How does one recognise a counterfeit of a supposed Montblanc wallet from eBay stock?

A wallet offered on eBay with an unusual division is likely actually a counterfeit, since Montblanc has not produced an article with this inner division. Typical indications are coarse, untidy seams, a formless-looking workmanship as well as the absence of usual equipment features like a hard-money compartment. Suspicious are additionally providers who sell several supposedly gifted branded articles in short intervals in parallel. In case of doubt, the authenticity should be compared to known originals or the purchase refrained from.


Where can the Meisterstück Unicef Edition ballpoint still be acquired?

If the writing instruments are no longer available in regular trade, a direct enquiry to Montblanc whether remaining stock still exists is first worthwhile. Should this not be the case, essentially the second-hand market, especially eBay, remains as source. There older editions turn up regularly; however, authenticity and condition should be heeded.


Is a Montblanc case with the designation "Oxford" an original?

The case "Oxford" is a real Montblanc product from the 1970s to 1980s, qualitatively however clearly settled below the later Siena cases. It was intended as a cheaper variant, among others, for the Slimline and Noblesse models. The designation can be found on an enclosed cardboard strip together with the model number 2450 and the article number 12067. On the official website, this older range is no longer documented.


Which production periods and edition sizes do the Montblanc Donation Pens (Bernstein, Menuhin, Bach) have?

The Leonard Bernstein writing instruments were produced about 1999 to 2001, the Yehudi Menuhin pieces 2001 to 2003; official quantities are not known. The Bach fountain pen appeared in February 2001, was planned to 12,000 pieces, the ballpoint to 8,000. Unlike the other Donation Pens, the Bach models bore an individual edition number on the cap. The stated final figures were however not quite reached, since the pieces delivered at the start did not yet receive an engraving and the production ended at the availability of the clips; in total significantly less than 20,000 Bach writing instruments were made.


How reliable are warranty slips on eBay auctions for Montblanc writing instruments?

Warranty slips too are being counterfeited; not seldom one receives a complete counterfeit including packaging and service guide. A warranty slip and an original packaging do have their own value but do not replace an authenticity check on the writing instrument itself. Important is not to be impressed by externals, since the combinations range from genuine pen with false slip to false pen with genuine slip. Initialling without a clearly recognisable seller's stamp is therefore no reliable authenticity proof.


Which older Montblanc models (1940–1970) with a flexible gold nib are suitable for beginners with a budget under 150 euros?

An unambiguous recommendation does not exist, since the individual writing behaviour varies strongly. Worthwhile is a look at models from the 40s and 50s, alongside the classical Meisterstücks also the cheaper variants of the second price series like the 24x, 25x and 34x ranges, whose nibs count as particularly soft. Before purchase it should be decided whether a free-standing or a partly hooded nib is preferred, as usual in the 50s to 70s. A BB nib grade can also write very softly; a try-out or specialised sources help with the choice.


May an administrator on a member's request delete all of their forum posts?

The deletion concerned not the regular forum posts but exclusively articles in the content area of the website, on which the author had all rights and which he could not directly remove himself. In such a case, the author's wish has priority, even if the loss of qualified contributions is regrettable. A separate section "Prices" is not provided in the forum. Regular postings are not removed on mere request but only on violations against the forum rules.


Can nibs also be exchanged on Montblanc Limited Editions and in which period is that possible?

As long as corresponding nibs are in stock, an exchange is basically possible, outside the 14-day period however mostly for a fee. A subsequent manufacture of individual nibs is, on the other hand, not practicable, because the tools needed for production are destroyed after expiry of an edition; only plans and drawings remain. Since nibs are made with specially fabricated stamping tools, an individual hand manufacture cannot be economically represented. For a concrete piece of information on a particular edition, a direct enquiry to Montblanc is recommended.


Why was the Unicef banner removed from the Fountainpen website?

The banners were always displayed free of charge and brought the operator no income. The reason for removal was demands of third parties to supplement the imprint by a VAT number, since a commercial activity was falsely assumed. Instead of banners, references to Unicef campaigns will in future take place editorially, e.g. via links. The website is expressly non-commercial, and the imprint was adapted to the requirements of the MDStV.


How is a writing instrument with built-in camera function (e.g. Hyundai Silver Eye) to be classified in data-protection terms and practically?

Devices with inconspicuous camera function raise considerable data-protection questions, since secret recordings are not permitted in many situations. Comparable are smartpens like the Livescribe models, which however primarily serve audio recording and digitisation of notes and are usually used with the consent of conversation partners. The Hyundai Silver Eye is unlikely to establish itself on the market, especially since successors with higher resolution like the Golden Eye already exist. Users should in any case check whether corresponding recordings are legally permissible.


What can be the cause when a long-stored Bohème fountain pen after filling does not write?

Most frequent cause is insufficient cleaning before storage; dried ink — especially black — can block the feed. A thorough cleaning with lukewarm water solves the problem in many cases. With a roughly six-year-old Bohème from an official specialist retailer, a counterfeit is very unlikely, since counterfeiters only after market establishment dare copies of new models. If the writing instrument despite cleaning remains dry, it should be presented to a dealer or to the manufacturer for assessment.


Are the Montblanc publications, e.g. "In einer Zeit rasender Geschwindigkeit" or the "Kleine Chronik des Hauses", still available?

The book "In einer Zeit rasender Geschwindigkeit…" is not yet too old and was at least in individual boutiques, e.g. at KaDeWe, handed out on request. A direct enquiry to Montblanc is sensible; the manufacturer occasionally refers, with out-of-print titles, to specialist magazines like "Schreibkultur" and "Kult am Pult", which partly still have remaining copies. Auction platforms can also be a source. Older publications like the "Kleine Chronik" are regularly hardly still to be obtained.


How does one recognise that a found Montblanc ballpoint is a counterfeit, and what value does it have?

Often the counterfeit is already recognisable at first glance, because the model has never existed in this form at Montblanc. A typical example are poor copies of the StarWalker; for comparison the section "Counterfeits" of the relevant collector sites helps. Economically, such pieces are worthless: in China they cost 2 to 3 euros for tourists; in Germany the distribution is anyway forbidden. A sale on eBay is therefore not permitted and should not take place.


What is known about the Solitaire Nikolai (Platinum) regarding production time, prices and authenticity check?

The Nikolai Platinum was officially produced from 2000 to 2002 but was still for some years in sale; official quantities are not available, since it is no Limited Edition. The retail prices were in 2000 for the Classique fountain pen around 825 euros, in 2002 895 euros; currently Classique models are offered used at about 895 euros, LeGrand variants significantly higher. To the equipment belonged a special outer sleeve and an additional booklet; otherwise the scope of delivery corresponds to the other Meisterstücks. An authenticity check via the serial number is basically possible at Montblanc, ideally via a specialist retailer; a reliable value forecast, however, cannot be made.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire fineliner in carbon look with finely laser-engraved serial number an original?

The model described corresponds to the Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire Silver Fibre Guilloche, which is documented on the relevant information pages of the collector community. The features like finely rounded logo corners and the laser-engraved serial number speak for an original. Visual deviations from current collections, e.g. missing ridges on the cap, can be explained by the older model range. For detail comparisons, a look at the product-related pictures in the collector archive is recommended.


How can a leaking Meisterstück 25 (Safety pen) be re-sealed?

For the repair new seals are needed; a competent point of contact is the workshop of Max Schrage (maxpens.de), which fits the seals professionally. If the nib after cleaning slips back during writing, this is mostly because the seal does not show the necessary radial preload. With the installation of a new, correctly preloaded seal, both the leakage and the nib problem can be remedied in one step. A self-repair is, without experience with Safety pens, not recommendable.


What should be considered when buying a Montblanc Monte Rosa, especially from abroad?

The Monte Rosa model 042 has a barrel diameter of 11.6 mm, a length without cap of 114 mm and with screwed-on cap of 127 mm. Gold trim can tarnish even without ink contact, which does not necessarily reduce the value. With foreign purchase, additional costs for money transfer and especially customs are to be calculated — the customs costs can reach around 30 percent of the goods value. Therefore, before a bid, a complete cost calculation should always be drawn up.


Can one judge from pictures whether a Montblanc 144 is genuine?

With a Montblanc 144 assessed via pictures, in particular the appearance of the nib speaks for an original; counterfeit Montblancs with real nibs are not known. A reliable confirmation, however, additionally requires the assessment of further details like clip, engravings and serial numbers. In the concrete case described, the piece is assessed as very likely genuine.


How is the article "Gewinnbringende Edelfedern" of "Welt am Sonntag" on investment in writing instruments to be evaluated?

The article is in the collector community predominantly seen critically. Especially the quantities named are regarded as misleading, since they do not correctly reproduce the actually produced amounts. Writing instruments are as a pure investment only conditionally suitable; collecting-technical and personal aspects stand in the foreground. Sound information is to be found rather in specialised collector circles and specialist publications than in general business sections.


Where can the Galileo TV report on the creation of the "Prince Rainier III Limited Edition 81" be watched, and what added value do Montblanc's official online channels offer?

The complete Galileo episode can be retrieved via the online archive of ProSieben as a Flash stream; there the respective current issue can be found. The German-language version too is accessible this way, not only the English variant. The official Facebook page of Montblanc offers a direct channel, but the content added value is, according to the assessment of the discussants, manageable. For more in-depth information on Limited Editions, specialist forums and boutiques are the more productive sources.


What is known about the old Montblanc letter cards with historical poster motifs and are they still available?

The individually packaged greeting cards were issued about ten years ago by Montblanc and distributed via selected top dealers, with manageable success. Originally there were ten different motifs; four have for some time been sold out; the remaining six are only kept in very small remaining quantities by individual dealers "under the counter". About six years ago they were officially taken out of the programme. Meanwhile Montblanc offers new cards in ten-packs at around 29.50 euros with more modern motifs that are no longer fully printed.


Why does a Montblanc 146 nib give significantly under during writing and spread sideways, and what can be done about it?

Older Montblanc nibs are generally significantly more flexible than today's and also more flexible than comparable Pelikan nibs, so a certain giving is normal. A lateral spreading, however, often indicates a bent nib, which cannot be clarified by remote diagnosis; an assessment in a Montblanc boutique or by a specialist is recommended. Excessive ink flow can also be down to the feed or to a leaking piston that draws extra air. An independent correction of the nib geometry is only restrictedly possible; in case of doubt, a nib exchange is the most reliable solution, which however can come close to the value of a new fountain pen.


How are the three writing instruments of the Max Reinhardt Edition (Salzburg Art Director's Pens) visually to be classified?

The various Salzburg Art Director's Pens, also designated as Max Reinhardt editions, are generally regarded as requiring some getting used to in design. The three pens discussed here are felt in this respect to be hardly surpassable. The taste judgement remains naturally individual. Content-historical details on the edition are not added in the thread.


How do the Montblanc 144 and the 145 (Chopin) differ in size?

The differences between 144 and 145 Chopin have already been extensively treated in the forum and can be found via the search function. New information on the dimensions was not added in the concrete thread; reference is made to the existing posts on the size and on the writing feel of the two models. A search via the forum search delivers here the most reliable information.


Where does one obtain a matching converter for the Sheaffer Connaisseur?

Matching converters for the Sheaffer Connaisseur are available from the specialist trade of Rolf Thiel (missing-pen.de). There the article is listed in the online shop and can be directly ordered. A self-adaptation of other converters is not necessary. The Sheaffer models count among collectors as very recommendable.


What book recommendation is there on the 250-year history of Faber-Castell?

Recommended is the jubilee book "Faber-Castell Since 1761 – Die illustrierte Geschichte einer Bleistiftdynastie", which appeared on the occasion of the 250-year company jubilee 2011. On Amazon, the book can be browsed online beforehand, which conveys a good impression of the contents. It is suitable both for collectors and for historically interested persons around the topic of pencil and writing culture.


Does the Pelikan ballpoint K400 have a thread of plastic or of brass, and is a plastic version original?

The Pelikan K400 exists both with plastic and with brass thread; both variants are original versions. The change to the brass thread took place presumably at the end of the 1990s or the early 2000s. A plastic thread is therefore no indication of a repair, an assembly from parts or a confusion with the 200. Both variants are found on auction platforms.


What can be the cause of a striking smell reminiscent of vomit on the Faber-Castell Castell 10 from the 60s/70s?

Such a striking smell is not normal and does not occur on most fountain pens. Most frequent cause are ink residues, e.g. from mouldy ink; a thorough cleaning with water is therefore the first step. If that does not help, the material processed itself can be the cause, since other writing instruments too can smell unpleasant due to material. To cover, a scented ink can if applicable be used; if the smell remains permanently, material ageing as cause is likely.


When and where does the next CAS collectors' get-together take place in January 2005?

The first CAS collectors' get-together of the year 2005 took place on 30 January 2005 from 14:00 (lunch from 13:00) in the restaurant "Zum Franziskaner", Düsseldorfer Straße 21, 44143 Dortmund. Participating were six collectors, of whom several from the first acquaintance meetings as well as newcomers from the forum and the personal circle of acquaintances. Registration ran via the organiser's contact address. Further information on the regional collectors' meet-ups can be found on the association page.


What price is reasonable for a new, originally packaged Montblanc Ramses II 146, and how everyday-suitable is it?

The new price was originally over 1,000 euros; on eBay, depending on condition, about 550 to 700 euros are usual; a dealer offer around 798 euros for a new, originally packaged piece counts as fair. Since vermeil surfaces scratch easily, when buying used, attention should be paid to scratch marks. The Ramses II is everyday-suitable; all writing instruments with metal surface are however somewhat scratch-sensitive. On travel, protection in a matching case from Montblanc is recommended.


Are the nibs of the older Montegrappa Espressione (with silver fittings) of steel or of gold, and how can this be checked?

On the older Espressione models, by experience, it is 18-carat gold nibs; steel variants are not known in this range. Gold nibs are basically marked by an imprint with the gold specification, which here however can be missing. For checking, a direct comparison with documented originals or an assessment by a specialist is recommended. Without an imprint a final residual uncertainty remains, but a steel nib is on this model very unlikely.


Is a price of around 2,900 euros for a Montblanc Hemingway fountain pen realistic?

Almost 3,000 euros are predominantly assessed as clearly excessive; realistic depending on condition appear about 1,500 to 1,800 euros, in individual cases also less. With an absolutely shop-new, sealed example in the original packaging, collectors in private sale can however quite call up 2,900 euros and more, especially with auctions with competing collectors. On eBay such peak prices are rarely achieved; at the same time fraud risk and authenticity problem are higher there. Overall the edition with 20,000 pieces was comparatively large, which should be reflected in the pricing.


Which model is an unusually-looking ballpoint offered as "Montblanc"?

The piece in question is a counterfeit of a Scenium ballpoint. The workmanship looks unaesthetic and does not correspond to the originals. Such copies have no collector value and should not be further sold. An identification as an original is here ruled out.


Is it unusual that Montblanc writing instruments on eBay can be financed by instalment payment?

Instalment financing is widespread on eBay for many high-priced auction articles and is nothing special for Montblanc writing instruments. The seller thereby receives his money immediately; the buyer pays in instalments to the financier. An instalment payment is, however, always more expensive than direct purchase and must be serviced until repayment. Anyone who cannot directly afford a writing instrument should therefore refrain from financing.


Which changes does the update of the forum software of the Fountainpen forum bring with it?

During the about 30-minute maintenance, the forum was raised to a more recent software version, above all to close possible security gaps. On the layout only minor changes were made; new are, among others, additional buttons, e.g. a direct link to the forum rules. Functionally, the forum remains largely unchanged usable for users. In terms of content, no posts are lost thereby.


How is the "Welt am Sonntag" report "Die echten Edelfedern" on investment in writing instruments to be evaluated?

The contribution is assessed as superficial and partly outdated – for example, the group affiliation of brands is no longer correctly represented, since Omas at the time of publication had for some time no longer belonged to LVMH. In terms of content too, the statements on quantities and value developments are partly inaccurate. Writing instruments are as an investment object only conditionally suitable and should be acquired primarily out of collector interest. Sound information is to be found rather in specialised collector circles.


Is a reduced Bohème "Noir et Noir" for 300 euros worthwhile, and how does the Jungle Eyes fit in price-wise?

The regular list price of the Bohème Noir et Noir is around 395 euros, so 300 euros at a closing specialist retailer is a fair offer. Important is not to confuse the "Noir et Noir" with the later "Bohème Noir"; both models differ visually and were produced in different periods. The Jungle Eyes lay price-wise between about 850 and 950 euros, depending on the model size – the 114 Mozart variant was cheaper than the 144. With new writing instruments, discounts are usually small; in specialist trade the risk of being taken advantage of is low.


How can one recognise that a pen allegedly coming from Montblanc is a fantasy product and thus a counterfeit?

With pieces unambiguously recognisable as counterfeits, the model has never existed in this form in the original range; the entire design is a fantasy product. Apart from the applied star, in such cases no detail fits a real Montblanc model, which points to cheap reproductions without serious imitation intent. Helpful for one's own assessment is comparison with documented original ranges on collector sites. Missing certificates are an additional warning sign.


Which recognition features exist on current counterfeits, e.g. on the StarWalker and on the Meisterstück?

Frequent counterfeit variants comprise the StarWalker with rubber surface, easily recognisable by the black end piece, as well as versions in red and white that were not offered like this in the original. On the Meisterstück too, fakes turn up repeatedly, both as individual pieces and as sets. The counterfeits look generally optically inconsistent and in workmanship clearly below original quality. Before purchase, a comparison with the corresponding collector sites on original models should take place.


How can one judge the authenticity of a Montblanc Octavian?

Important indications are a complete documentation and especially matching numbers on the warranty card and on the fountain pen itself. If these papers with correctly assigned edition number are present and pictures and description match known originals, an authentic piece is most likely to be assumed. Especially with rare Limited Editions like the Octavian, such proofs are a central authenticity criterion. In case of doubt, an additional assessment by a specialist should take place.


Can the production date of a Montblanc Meisterstück be ascertained based on the serial or clip-ring number?

The production date cannot be read off the clip-ring number. Neither Montblanc nor the trade have an interest in making lying times or concrete production dates transparent. For the end customer too, this information is generally not relevant, since quality and warranty are not tied to the production date. A temporal classification is at most roughly possible via the model, the nib design and the scope of delivery.


Who can repair a Montblanc Slimline Noblesse 1122 if the manufacturer rejects the repair due to a lack of replacement nib?

Since the Noblesse 1122 (1978–1980) was a model of the cheaper class and has not been produced for over 25 years, it is understandable that Montblanc no longer keeps replacement nibs. Economically, a repair is anyway seldom sensible, since a well-preserved replacement device is often cheaper to obtain on eBay than any repair flat rate. A lifetime warranty on writing instruments of this price class is also unrealistic with other manufacturers and is hardly granted even on significantly higher-quality products. Anyone nevertheless wishing to have it repaired can turn to specialised writing-instrument workshops.


Did the Montblanc Limited 1924 Anniversary Edition really include sunglasses?

In the catalogue for the 75th Anniversary Edition, sunglasses with black frame, round dark lenses and mother-of-pearl star with rose-gold rim on the temple were depicted or drawn. Actually produced and sold, however, such glasses were according to current knowledge not – neither within the framework of the 1924 edition nor of the Special Anniversary Edition. Possibly they were originally planned but did not come into series. Reliable original examples have not surfaced in collector circles.


Must an original Montblanc 234 1/2 necessarily have a nib with the designation 4 1/2, and what does the 1/2 in the model designation mean?

According to the reference "Collectible Stars", the 234 1/2 was built not only with a gold nib but also with a steel nib, although only in the normal version and not in the luxury variant. A 585 gold nib is thus one but not the only original configuration. The designation 1/2 is part of the model system and does not necessarily allow conclusions about a specific nib inscription. For a final authenticity judgement, nib inscription and model variant must be considered together.


Does a Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire Faden Guilloche bear at the tip the engraving "MONTBLANC", and what does that say about the authenticity of an eBay offer?

The piece offered in the named auction is a counterfeit, even if a comparatively well-made one. The engraving at the tip does not agree with the original conventions. Generally, when buying branded products on eBay, caution is in order, since counterfeits are difficult to recognise for laypersons based on photos. Collector sales of reputable providers are by contrast quite a source, provided seller profile and description are critically checked.


Has Montblanc actually produced simple imitation-leather cases with snap-button fastener, or is it a counterfeit?

Even a simple, black imitation-leather case with snap-button fastener and star logo can be an original. Until the repositioning as a luxury manufacturer from 1991, Montblanc produced the entire spectrum from the cheap school fountain pen to the high-quality Meisterstück and correspondingly also simpler accessories. Cases from the 50s therefore often appear "cheap" compared to later leather versions but are nevertheless authentic. A simple visual or material impression does not suffice to rule out originality.


What is known about the Montblanc Skeleton Edition "Gaudi", and where are pictures of it available?

The edition named is a skeleton fountain pen whose design is oriented on the architecture of Antoni Gaudí. A content connection of Montblanc to Gaudí cannot be clearly derived from the posts. Pictures and further impressions of the piece can be found on the collector site cruzaltpens.com in the post on the model. As with many special editions, the design is a matter of taste; in collector circles, the Gaudi is overall positively received.


From what period does the Montblanc 334 with the barrel engraving "D.R.P. angem." come?

The Montblanc 334 was produced in the years 1935 to 1936 and is thus the immediate predecessor of the better-known model 334 1/2. The designation "D.R.P. angem." stands for "Deutsches Reichspatent angemeldet" (German Reich patent applied for) and is typical for writing instruments from this period. Information on the internet is rare on this model, since it was only briefly made.


Which model is a gilded Montblanc rollerball with longitudinal grooves, and what is known about material and original retail price?

It is a Montblanc Noblesse rollerball from the third and last series of the Noblesse range (not to be confused with the later Noblesse Oblige range), produced at the end of the 1990s. The material is gilded brass, with the gilding very thin and rubbing off comparatively quickly. The blank, shiny field on the cap is regularly intended as an engraving field; a hallmark or serial number does not exist on these pieces. The then retail price was about 125 to 135 DM, by which the model was significantly cheaper than the black Meisterstück rollerballs of plastic.


What do the engravings on a Montblanc Meisterstück with imprint "Deutsche Bahn EUR bln 6%2010" mean, and how can the value be assessed?

Pens with such imprints are to be classified as advertising pens, that is, special productions with company or occasion engraving. A serious value statement for non-current, used writing instruments is generally not possible, especially not for advertising examples. In the forum such evaluations are not made for basic considerations. The letter abbreviations with numbers are the regular serial numbers of the Meisterstücks, followed by the origin specification "Germany".


How can the authenticity of a fountain pen auctioned on eBay be assessed, and is the price paid appropriate?

Based on the pictures, only a first authenticity suspicion can be formulated; absolute certainty exists only when the actually delivered piece can be checked. If the seller is known and respected in the collector scene, the risk drops considerably. Compared to the official new price of around 425 euros, eBay prices can lie significantly below, which with renowned providers can nevertheless be a fair deal. An additional check by a specialist retailer or experienced collectors is always recommendable.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire Ceramics Black Prisma with shifted serial number and clip engraving "Made in Germany" genuine?

A slightly offset serial number on the cap ring does not speak against authenticity; on Montblanc such tolerances occur. The clip engraving "Made in Germany" is also regular: on older writing instruments there the engraving "PIX" is found; on newer models it was replaced by "Made in Germany". If the other details match, the piece can be classified as an original. A definitive authenticity confirmation can however only be given by Montblanc itself.


Why do the decorative rings on a Montblanc Meisterstück 142 loosen, and how can the defect be remedied?

The body and cap materials of older Meisterstücks consist of celluloid, which shrinks over the course of decades. As a result, the placed decorative rings come loose and can rotate or even fall off. A repair with adhesives like Uhu is not recommended. Instead one should turn to a specialised restorer for vintage fountain pens who can professionally re-fix the ring.


Does it speak against the authenticity of a Montblanc 163 rollerball if only "W-Germany" stands on the clip and no serial number is laser-engraved?

Serial numbers were laser-engraved into the clip as standard at Montblanc only from about 1991. The engraving "W. Germany" indicates that the writing instrument was made before reunification 1989, so the missing serial number is in this case normal and does not speak against authenticity. Without pictures, however, no final judgement can be made. In case of doubt, the piece should be presented to a specialist retailer.


Are "waves" or deformations around the clip ring of a Montblanc writing instrument a defect or normal wear?

A remote-diagnostic judgement is difficult; a comparison with a display piece in the Montblanc specialist shop is sensible. If a defect is actually present and the purchase is less than two years ago, the clip can be exchanged within the warranty on presentation of the receipt free of charge at the factory. Outside the warranty, the repair costs for a clip exchange move between about 49 and 79 euros, which at the new prices of the writing instruments counts as appropriate.


Can a Parker Duofold Special with inscription "GEO.S.PARKER-PEN-MADE IN U.S.A PATENTED" be a counterfeit?

The pen is a vintage Parker that was presumably made before 1945, in the 1930s, in the USA. Counterfeits of historical Parker writing instruments of this construction have so far not turned up, so the authenticity risk is low. The housing consists of celluloid; the nib is solidly made of gold. To be noted is that the Vacumatic filling technique is hard to repair in Europe, since corresponding special knowledge and tools are seldom available.


How can a fountain-pen collection be sensibly managed on the computer?

A simple Excel sheet is generally completely sufficient for managing a fountain-pen collection. The advantage of this solution is that every spreadsheet can be individually adapted to the respective collector's piece and photos can be embedded without problem. Special management software or a CD-ROM is not necessary for this purpose.


Which costs are to be expected for the repair of a bent nib of a Montblanc Voltaire?

If the nib only has to be straightened, costs up to about 100 euros are to be reckoned with. A complete nib exchange moves, by experience, between 200 and 300 euros, which on the Voltaire economically still remains sensible. A binding estimate is only made by Montblanc service in Hamburg, which is why the writing instrument must be sent in directly or via a specialist retailer. After receipt of the quote, it can be decided whether the repair is carried out or the piece is returned unrepaired.


Which Meisterstück model is a black-gold fountain pen with 135 mm length, serial number "X 61781150" and 14K nib?

With the dimensions and properties mentioned, it is a Meisterstück 144. A monochrome yellow-gold nib with longitudinally ribbed nib holder points to an older variant of the model, e.g. from the 1980s. This variant differs from the later bicolour nibs but is unambiguously to be classified as a 144.


To whom can one turn to have the value and age of old Pforzheim ballpoints with brand names like "Sarastro" or "Admiral" assessed?

For the evaluation of such older ballpoints, an enquiry to Dirk Barmeyer offers itself, e.g. via the platform penexchange.de. The collector community for such ballpoint brands is small, which correspondingly affects the market value. If anyone can give well-founded information, it is most likely this specialist.


Is a reddish-brown leather case in the style of a Montblanc Siena without metal ring around the logo an original or a counterfeit?

At first glance, much speaks for an original, since imprint and further details fit Montblanc cases of this type. Unusual, however, is the absence of the metal ring around the logo, since this was actually standard. A definitive authenticity evaluation can only be given by Montblanc customer service, e.g. via the contact form on the official homepage. To be noted is that there is no "one" counterfeiter but many different sources with strongly varying quality, so no individual detail reliably proves authenticity.


Is the purchase of a Montblanc wallet worthwhile, or are there more robust alternatives?

If a wallet is regularly carried in the back pocket, even a Montblanc model rarely lasts longer than a year without visible wear. As a more long-lasting alternative, the brand Bree is named, whose soft leather adapts better to deformations. Another option is the English solution with coins carried loose in the front pocket and banknotes in a clip, which increases seat comfort and overview. Before purchase, a visit to a boutique is recommended in order to check the quality directly.


Did the Montblanc Unicef campaign "Sign up for the right to write" include 149 fountain pens with engraved inscription of personalities like Sarkozy?

The campaign indeed comprised 149 fountain pens engraved with the signature of a respective personality. In total 149 persons from politics, culture and art gave a handwritten statement, which was subsequently auctioned together with the engraved fountain pen and a photo in an about 60-by-60-centimetre plexiglass frame via eBay. There is confusion risk with the 4810 packagings of Sachs, Jahn and Putman, which contain plain 149s without engraving. Whether Sarkozy was officially involved cannot be unambiguously confirmed from the available lists.


Of which material does the Montblanc 28 ballpoint consist, and how can it be polished up without damaging the gilding?

The Montblanc 28, presumably from the 1970s or 1980s, consists of normal plastic, since Montblanc has only been positioned as a luxury manufacturer since 1991. A refurbishment by Montblanc itself is on this model not economically sensible. Polishes act like fine abrasive material and can quickly remove the generally very thin gilding of clips and rings, which is why one should work with fine grit and only in daylight. A counterfeit is on this model de facto ruled out, since the former market value would not have made a counterfeit worthwhile; with missing model number and inscription "W. Germany", a model of the Classic range is presumably present.


Is a Montblanc 146 with B nib that is said to be three to four years old and "only written in" reasonably valued at 300 euros?

How often a fountain pen was written with is largely irrelevant for the condition of the nib: gold nibs have an iridium tipping at the tip that survives many generations of intensive use without measurable change. Statements like "only written in" or "broken in" are from a collector's view rather marketing formulas. The exact age too is mostly not unambiguously ascertainable, since writing instruments are partly stored in trade for years. With B nibs, which are more frequently offered than F or EF, it is worthwhile comparing several offers and not rushing the purchase.


Which edition sizes and which gemstones characterise the Montblanc Artisan editions like "True Princess", "White Pearl" and "Jungle Eyes"?

Montblanc gives no official quantities on these Special Editions, so only estimates are possible; the editions of "Jungle Eyes" and "True Princess" lie presumably below those of the Writers Edition, since the expensive pieces sold worse. Particularly rare is the White Pearl Edition, since it was never officially offered and is moreover the only Meisterstück without the three cap rings; it was initially delivered only in Germany. The stones used in the Jungle Eyes editions are: green = tourmaline, cognac = Madeira citrine, yellow = Palmeira citrine, purple = amethyst, blue = topaz; white (mother-of-pearl) and black (onyx) belonged to the Gift Collection 2004. Mozart sizes are overall rarer to encounter than the 144 sizes.


How can counterfeits of Montblanc writing instruments be reported on eBay?

Ebay has under the section "Contact" a reporting tool with which auctions of plagiarisms can be directly reported to the platform. After entering the report, the reporter automatically receives a confirmation to the deposited email address. In practice, such offers are frequently removed by eBay after a short time. The active use of this tool is recommended in order to make market access more difficult for plagiarism providers.


Is a Montblanc 144 with a completely smooth hard-rubber feed without grooves an original, and does it actually come from the 1970s?

The piece described is an original 144 from the 1980s, not from the 1970s. The variant with a completely smooth feed without grooves was actually delivered in this time and is not unusual. Authenticity problems therefore do not exist. The frequently demanded price of around 219 euros is, however, ambitious; used older 144s are available on the market already from about 80 euros.


What significance do the model numbers like 146 or 149 have in the Montblanc Meisterstück series?

The numbers simply denote the respective model within the Meisterstück series and differentiate size and equipment of the writing instruments, comparable to model classes of other brand manufacturers. A complete overview of the numbering together with the matching writing instruments can be found on relevant collector sites. Via the subpages linked there, further model information can also be accessed.


Is a non-centred hyphen between "Meisterstück" and "Montblanc" on the cap of a Meisterstück 144 a sign of a production error or a counterfeit?

Neither one nor the other: with the imprints by Montblanc there have been and are numerous different variants, and the positioning seems partly inconsistent. It can be assumed that this aspect was not strictly standardised in production. A decentralised hyphen is therefore no reliable authenticity criterion. An official authenticity guarantee can exclusively Montblanc issue after sending in the piece.


How do the Montblanc StarWalker and the Bohème differ as fountain pens, and which model is rather to be recommended?

Both fountain pens are officially designed for cartridge operation, with on the StarWalker a converter also being usable without problem. The StarWalker counts as the more progressive writing instrument in design and material; its nib consists of 585 gold and is available in the strengths F to B. The Bohème is more classical and distinguished and has a peculiarity: the nib is turned back into the body after use, which makes it less suitable for quick notes. Which model better fits depends on design preferences and usage behaviour.


Which fountain pen in the price range around 150 euros with a piston filling system is suitable for a rather small handwriting?

Waterman drops out due to the stated criteria, as does a Pelikan, whose models in this price class tend to fall too small for the requirements. The Lamy 2000 is a recommendable choice for the described usage purpose. The often heard myth that an EF nib has a worse ink flow than an M nib does not apply; decisive are matching ink (e.g. Lamy Royal Blue) as well as the care condition of the fountain pen. With small handwriting, practically only EF, F or MK come into question; a test in a well-stocked specialist shop with qualified advice is sensible.


Which Montblanc model could a pen with silver clip, ring and nib without model number be, whose star at the end piece is set lower?

Based on the features described, an unambiguous identification is difficult. In question come, e.g., a Montblanc 320, but the clip rather suggests a model 420; then, however, the nib does not fit. Possible is a mixed construction from parts of a 320 and a 420 cap. The individual components in any case stem from the 1970s.


Should the nib of a Montblanc 149 from the Unicef Edition be three-part, and which nib width regularly belongs to the set?

With an offer with a two-tone instead of three-part nib, it is to be assumed that an older 149 from the 1980s or early 1990s was inserted into the Unicef packaging. Limited Editions can however at Montblanc also be individually ordered in a deviating nib width, e.g. if the standard width M is felt to be too broad. An F nib in the Unicef set is therefore indeed untypical but can be legitimate. The sets regularly come with an M nib.


Is an older-looking Montblanc ballpoint from an unknown model an original?

The model mentioned is an original ballpoint that was produced in the period 1961 to 1970. Such pieces are relatively frequently to be encountered on the market. For this reason, the collector value remains within manageable limits.


Why is there a coil spring inside the piston converter of a Montblanc Meisterstück 144?

The coil spring in the converter is intentional and occurs regularly on Montblanc converters; it controls the ink guidance or flow behaviour. In the forum there are several posts under the keyword "Spirale" that extensively deal with the function and meaning of this component. As long as the function of the converter is not impaired, there is no reason for maintenance by Montblanc service.


Are a dust inclusion in front of the diamond of a Montblanc StarWalker as well as pronounced scratches on the barrel of a Scenium reasons for complaint?

If on the StarWalker actually a production defect like an enclosed dust particle in front of the diamond is present, that is within the warranty period subject to complaint at the seller; a filled-in warranty certificate is required for this. The complaint can also take place in another Montblanc-owned boutique, not necessarily where it was bought; with concessionaires this does not apply for fairness reasons. On the Scenium rollerball, abrasion of the matt lacquer by friction with clip or cap is material-typical normal and is no reason for complaint, especially since the model is for Montblanc conditions regarded as inexpensive.


Do counterfeits of the Montblanc Document Marker exist, and what significance does the black dot in the clip have?

The black dot in the clip is a regular marking that serves to distinguish the Document Marker in the case from same-format pens. If this dot is missing, that indicates in doubt that it has fallen off; the piece remains, however, genuine. Older Markers of the LeGrand series originally did not have different clips, so examples without dot can also be original. Specific counterfeits of the Document Marker are not widespread.


What should be considered with a first Montblanc purchase, e.g. a Platinum Line 165 mechanical pencil from eBay classifieds, regarding authenticity?

There are numerous counterfeit features, which vary depending on the model. A helpful indicator for an original is the inscription "Pix" under the clip, which must not be engraved but executed as raised protrusion. Basically, it is recommended before purchase to thoroughly study original photos on the Montblanc homepage and only to buy models that are visually beyond doubt familiar. A definitive authenticity evaluation based on photos, however, remains restricted.


Which Montblanc model is the Meisterstück Ceramics Black Prisma, and is there a counterfeit risk?

It is the Ceramics Black Prisma variant of the Montblanc Meisterstück, a special variant of the regular model. On the pictures presented, no counterfeit can be recognised. An official guarantee for authenticity can however only be given by a specialist retailer or Montblanc itself. To be noted is that the barrel of these models scratches relatively easily; with a suitable cleaning cloth, surface traces can however be remedied again.


Is it reputable on eBay auctions to demand a fee per line of information about a fountain pen?

The procedure described is assessed by experienced collectors as disreputable and does not correspond to the usual practices among collectors. Added to this is that on eBay it is forbidden in an auction to refer to one's own website. Often such offers are less real collector service than an advertising measure for one's own books or websites. Collectors support each other in relevant forums typically free of charge.


How can beginners assess the appropriateness of prices for vintage fountain pens, e.g. on eBay?

As orientation aid the book "CollectibleStars" is recommended, which delivers not only rough price ranges but above all also assessments of the rarity of the individual writing instruments. The rarity is often the more important indication for realistic market prices than the pure price specification. Important, however, is that all statements presuppose a good preservation condition; damages or strong wear reduce the value significantly. The book is available via relevant collector sites and also directly at collectors' meet-ups.


Does the Montblanc 149 also exist from the factory with platinum-plated instead of gilded trim?

Montblanc has produced the 149 exclusively with gilded trim; an official variant with platinum-plated or rhodium-plated trim does not exist. Pieces with silver-shiny trim therefore arise subsequently, by the originally gilded trim being rhodium-plated. Such conversions are no factory states but individual changes outside the regular model programme.


Which barrel diameters, model designations and nib-width abbreviations do the Montblanc pens from the 1950s and 1960s show?

In the 1950s and 1960s Montblanc produced piston fountain pens designed by Graf Goertz in two sizes: the x2 range with a barrel diameter of 11.5 millimetres and a total length of 128 millimetres with the cap closed as well as the x4 range with 12 millimetres barrel diameter and 135 millimetres length. Three model lines existed: the Meisterstücks (No. 12 and 14) with the stylised mountain as cap ring, a second range with two cap rings (No. 22 and 24) as well as, as better school or entry-level pens, the numbers 32 and 34. Production ran from 1958/59 to 1969. With nib widths, the abbreviations F stand for fine and M for medium; further variants of the series comprised additional strengths.


Is a Montblanc 139 with a flawlessly yellow ink window without visible stripes a counterfeit or an assembled body?

A yellow-looking, freshly appearing ink window without recognisable stripes is striking: if the fountain pen had been little used, the stripes would have to be present; if it had been heavily used, the window would have to be darkly discoloured by ink residues. Both speak against an unchanged original body. Also the nib looks compared to the rest of the older components like the D.R.P. number possibly younger. Overall the piece thus appears dubious and suggests that at least the body or parts of it were subsequently made or brought together.


Are a missing 925 stamp and a "W-Germany" inscription without serial number in the clip plausible on a Montblanc Solitaire with brass body and silver corn guilloche?

This constellation is plausible: writing instruments with brass body and silver corn guilloche bear no 925 stamp, and the inscription "W. Germany" points to a production before reunification 1989. Serial numbers were standard-introduced at Montblanc only after the fall of the Wall, which is why their absence is normal on these pieces. To what extent remaining stock of "W. Germany" clips was still fitted after 1990 is not finally clarified. With a consistent description, proper photos and a reliable seller, from a collector's view little speaks against the purchase.


Is a Montblanc set offered on Willhaben with strikingly-looking stars an original or a counterfeit?

The set described is a particularly crude counterfeit. A clear indication are the Montblanc stars, which look glued on instead of inset or integrated. Such plagiarisms are made in China for only one to two euros per piece. The purchase is unambiguously to be advised against.


How can the model number of an inherited Montblanc Meisterstück be determined, and can an engraved name engraving on the clip be removed?

An existing engraving on the clip can be most safely removed by exchanging the engraved spare part for a new one. Polishing is possible but mostly leaves a visible dent and is therefore not to be recommended. For model determination, comparison with overview pages on the classical Montblanc Meisterstücks is worthwhile, which list all common models together with pictures and dimensions. A realistic sale price can only be named after exact model assignment and condition evaluation.


How high were edition and price of the Montblanc Limited Edition "Ancient Games" for the 2004 Olympic Games?

The Limited Edition "Ancient Games" belonged to the Atelier Privés range and was sold in July 2004 exclusively via the Greek Montblanc boutiques. It was limited to 28 pieces. The body consists of solid yellow gold with a white marbled cap. The introduction price was 14,800 euros.


Is a Montblanc Solitaire Vermeil offered on eBay with unambiguous hallmark to be regarded as an original?

Based on the pictures, especially the recognisable hallmark, the Solitaire Vermeil looks very credibly like an original. The auction itself also makes a reputable impression. The risk thus appears overall low. An on-site collection from the seller would be the safest variant; if it is not possible, shipping with a reliable service provider is an acceptable alternative.


Are utopianly high retail prices (e.g. 59,000 euros) for a Montblanc 164 Demo on online auctions realistic?

Demo writing instruments are indeed rare but achieve on eBay typically only prices between 500 and 1000 euros. Demands of around 59,000 euros are completely unrealistic and count as a brazen attempt to fleece unsuspecting buyers. Such moon prices stand in no relation to the actual collector value.


Since when does Montblanc use laser-engraved identification numbers on its writing instruments, and how old can a rollerball without this number be?

Montblanc writing instruments from the 1980s and before do not yet have a laser-engraved identity engraving; these numbers were only introduced about ten years ago. Rollerballs themselves, however, only exist at Montblanc since the 1970s with the model Quickpen, and the Meisterstück programme offers rollerballs only since the 1980s. A rollerball without laser-engraved number can thus quite be two to three decades old but is no really old writing instrument in the narrower sense.


Why are source references to the web address embedded in forum photos and what effect does that have against unauthorised picture use?

Since photos of the forum page were repeatedly used without permission by third parties in online auctions, source references are copied directly into the pictures, while the copyrights remain with the photographer. Platforms like eBay generally automatically delete auction photos with embedded web address, so the unauthorised use practically resolves itself. Anyone who has contributed their own photos and is not satisfied with the concrete form of the watermark can request individual adjustments.


Is a Montblanc StarWalker Resin fountain pen with a striking thread and visible plastic on the grip section possibly a counterfeit?

Nib and feed of a StarWalker Resin sourced from online trade can quite correspond to the original, even if the thread visually deviates from examples in authenticity guides. A definitive evaluation of the grip-section material is difficult without inspection. For safeguarding, an authentication enquiry to Montblanc with the serial number is recommended.


How can one tell on eBay whether a Montblanc StarWalker Rubber ballpoint is genuine?

Based on auction photos, the authenticity of a StarWalker Rubber is mostly not unambiguously to be judged, and the risk remains that the depicted goods do not correspond to the delivered ones. Additionally, the rating history of the seller and the lack of a manufacturer's warranty in the eBay purchase are to be heeded. A provider known as reliable who only carries original goods can significantly reduce the risk; in case of doubt, the purchase from a specialist retailer is to be preferred.


Is a Montblanc Le Grand without PIX inscription on the back of the clip necessarily a counterfeit?

Older Meisterstücks, e.g. until the middle of the 1990s, do not yet bear a PIX engraving under the clip, so its absence is no unambiguous counterfeit feature. Counterfeit piston fillers in Meisterstück style are also extremely rare; most counterfeits concern other models. A final confirmation of the authenticity can be made by a Montblanc boutique.


Is a Montblanc Mozart 114 with reversed colouring of barrel and cap an official model?

A 114 variant with unusual colour or material combination between barrel and cap is as a regular factory product by Montblanc almost certainly to be ruled out. Probably original parts like cap, front part and nib were combined with a subsequently made, individual barrel. Such a writing instrument has not left the factory in this configuration.


Did Montblanc have a calendar pen, and what is known about it?

Montblanc bought in at the end of the 1950s to the early 1960s a calendar pen and offered it in combination with a pocket calendar or notepad in a leather sleeve. As refill, a 3/4-length seamstress refill was used, which today is no longer regularly available. The pen is therefore a rather rare collector's object from this era.


How can the authenticity of a Montblanc Cervantes offered on eBay be checked when the provider uses replica photos?

With the Cervantes, counterfeits frequently occur that are partly even visually confused with the Copernicus, because the counterfeiters themselves mix up the models. An authenticity check based solely on foreign or replica photos is not possible; in such cases the purchase is risky and not recommended. Replicas are sold for very low prices freely on the internet, which additionally aggravates the counterfeit problem.


Which Sheaffer model is a fountain pen with a characteristic nib, and how is it filled?

Based on the nib form, much speaks for a Sheaffer Crest. This model can be supplied with ink both via cartridges and via the for Sheaffer typical rubber-sac filling system. Which variant concretely is present can only be shown by inspection of the inside of the barrel.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück ballpoint with dedication engraving a rarity, and how does an engraving affect the value?

The offered ballpoint is genuine but not rare; a new, unengraved cap is at Montblanc available for at most about 49 euros. An individual name or dedication engraving is on pure utility pieces mostly regarded as value-reducing. It can however quite be value-increasing if the engraving documents a prominent owner and a comprehensible proof of ownership is available; in a concrete collector project, additionally, only 25 instead of the stated 1000 pieces were engraved.


What is an extremely slim Montblanc pencil with rotary mechanism and about 5 mm diameter, and is it to be classified as a PIX?

A very slim Montblanc pencil with rotary mechanism at the end part is no PIX but a rotary pencil. The designation PIX was originally reserved exclusively for push pencils before Montblanc used the name for other products for reasons of brand-protection law. There are additionally significantly smaller rotary pencils than the piece described.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück fountain pen with a plastic-looking, gold-coloured thread a counterfeit?

Such a piece is generally an original, however frequently not a 146 but the smaller 144. The 144 was made until the end of the 1990s; the example described should be based on the feed about from the late 1980s to early 1990s. The supposedly painted plastic on the thread is actually gilded brass.


Are an old piston fountain pen with imprint Student/Iona 454 and a Safety pen with Montblanc nib and imprint Rama-Post actually Montblanc writing instruments?

The piston fountain pen described is definitely no Montblanc; the material rather looks like post-war plastic, while the form recalls the 1930s, which points to a so-called no-name manufacturer. With the Safety pen, the nib clearly comes from Montblanc, but whether barrel and mechanism are also original parts can only be clarified by inspection. Since Montblanc at that time was already a premium manufacturer and children did not count among the target group, an advertising campaign with the children's magazine Rama-Post is very unlikely; manufacturers like KaWeCo or Soennecken would come into question.


How can one recognise that a supposed Montblanc Copernicus is a counterfeit?

Comparing the piece with real pictures of a Montblanc Copernicus, obvious differences are immediately noticeable, e.g. a red, gilded surface instead of the original decoration. The nib of such counterfeits is generally of very poor quality. Such plagiarisms are made in China for a few euros; in Germany their sale is not legally permissible.


Which model is an inherited Montblanc fountain pen from the 1940s to 1950s with an elaborate overlay?

Provided the nib is provided with the embossing 4810, everything points to a Montblanc 144 from the 1950s. The additionally present silver or precious-metal overlay was not made by Montblanc itself but by the firm B&E and applied subsequently.


How is the Montblanc Le Grand pencil 167 with 0.9 mm leads correctly reloaded?

The Le Grand pencil is basically reloaded from the front via the tip, not via the barrel. A slight play of the inserted lead can indicate that during turning too far back was turned, so the lead loses its hold. The exact instruction as well as hints on product care Montblanc provides on its website for download. Standard lead strength is 0.9 mm and noted on the loading compartment.


Are the Montblanc spectacle frames frequently offered on eBay together with case counterfeits?

The spectacle frame described looks together with the case genuine; on counterfeit writing-instrument packagings the inscription or star is generally black on a white background; here the arrangement is, however, correct. An unambiguous model confirmation was not possible based on the catalogues, since spectacle frames are a sideline area. When buying such spectacles, the way via specialist trade or the Montblanc boutique is basically recommended rather than via auction platforms.


Can a Montblanc Mozart with an 18-carat instead of 14-carat gold nib be genuine?

A Mozart with 18-carat nib is most likely an export model destined for the French market, where fountain pens are standard-equipped with 18-carat gold nibs. On the 149 too there were corresponding differences between domestic and export versions. Based on the photos nothing speaks against the authenticity of the writing instrument.


How can one judge whether an old ink bottle with glass body and supposed silver fitting is really antique?

Real historical silver overlays always bear a hallmark; if this is missing, the authenticity is questionable. On the market many artificially aged ink bottles are in circulation that are only between just under 20 and 30 euros worth. Even high-quality photos do not always allow reliable distinction between original and replica.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück 147 without box and receipt genuine, and is the asking price reasonable?

Based on the pictures, no indications of a counterfeit can be recognised, so the piece is most likely an original. The list price for the 147 is currently around 600 euros including travel case; a used example without warranty and original accessories for 275 euros is to be classified as ambitious but compared to other online offers still the cheapest. Anyone who does not urgently need a 147 generally fares better with some patience, since Traveller models are indeed rarer than 146s but are nevertheless offered repeatedly.


How can a Montblanc Meisterstück fountain pen with a completely gilded 14-carat nib, embossing Germany and without identity number be classified?

The combination of size, gilded 14-carat nib with M embossing and missing identity number on the cap ring speaks clearly for a Montblanc 144. The imprint Germany without the addition W.-Germany points to a production from 1989 onwards. On many 144s the gilding of the ring in front of the nib is typically attacked; careful polishing improves the look but cannot restore worn-off gildings.


Is a vintage gold-coloured Montblanc fountain pen with the nib embossings 4810, M, 140, MONTBLANC and 585 genuine, and what collector value does it have?

The writing instrument described corresponds to an original Montblanc from the late 1950s; due to the size it is presumably a 744 rather than a 742. Counterfeits of old vintage models are extremely rare and stem, if present, mostly from no-name vintage nibs that are visually easily to distinguish. This model is quite of interest for collectors and counts as a good everyday writing instrument; a concrete value statement can only be derived via realised sale prices of comparable examples.


Are water or condensation drops on the nib of a Montblanc StarWalker normal?

Condensation on the nib is a typical phenomenon when a writing instrument comes from a colder environment into a warmer room or is worn close to the body for a longer time. This also occurs on other models like 146 or 149, is unproblematic and does not impair writing. The drops evaporate by themselves after a few minutes.


Which Meisterstück variant is the most popular or best-selling?

Exact sales figures only Montblanc knows; the GFK also captures only the specialist trade and not the boutiques. In German specialist trade, the model 144/145 (Classique) lies clearly before the 146, while 149 and 114 Mozart hardly turn up due to small quantities; in the boutiques the gaps are smaller, but here too the Classique leads before the Le Grand. Internationally, the 149 is significantly more strongly positioned. Collector surveys often prefer Mozart and Le Grand but are not representative of the overall market.


How does one reliably recognise on eBay auction photos counterfeits like a false Scott Fitzgerald rollerball?

A reliable authenticity evaluation based on poor auction photos is for beginners often hardly possible; safer is the purchase from a specialist retailer or at collectors' fairs. Concrete recognition features for individual models and counterfeits are extensively described in the forum section Fälschungen erkennen. Anyone who internalises the topic can better assess typical weak points but should rather forgo online auctions with uncertainty.


What to do if a Montblanc 146P after a nib change in the boutique starts poorly, ink stands on top of the nib and the end piece no longer closes flush?

Ink above the nib between tip and breathing hole as well as untidy start-up mostly indicate that the nib after the change is not correctly seated. A second free exchange is generally not granted by Montblanc, so a renewed processing is sensible. Recommended is to pack the writing instrument shock-resistantly in bubble wrap and cardboard and to send with a covering letter directly to the Customer Service of Montblanc Simplo GmbH in Hamburg.


What price difference exists between the Montblanc Meisterstück Leather under-arm bags and the similar Platinum Leather bags?

The Meisterstück Leather under-arm bag cost until production discontinuation some years ago about 980 DM or around 500 euros; an Australian price of 1300 AUD corresponds to about 750 euros and lies thus above the then German shop price. The visually similar but stylistically different bag of the Platinum Leather series was made by Seeger and was price-wise just over the Meisterstück variant. Both ranges have not been offered by Montblanc for about three years, which explains the different resale price and bidding behaviour.


Is the Montblanc Heritage Collection 1914 Limited Edition 1000 worth its money at prices between 5,000 and 7,000 euros?

The value of a fountain pen is always subjective and is composed of the writing enjoyment as well as a hard-to-forecast resale value. Even particularly demanded models achieve on the secondary market very different prices, so an objective assessment is hardly possible. Without concrete experience values with the model, ultimately one's own gut feeling remains the essential decision basis.


Is a case offered as Montblanc Sienna case 906/2 from the 1970s to 1980s genuine?

The case shown comes from the 1970s to 1980s and is most likely an original, although a simple model from that time when Montblanc still carried a broad product range from school fountain pens to Meisterstücks. With the Sienna case, however, it has nothing to do; the designation in the offer is wrong. Anyone who ordered a real Sienna case should therefore insist on delivery of the correct model.


Where can information be found on model name, production time and collector value of an old Montblanc mechanical pencil and rotary fountain pen from before 1944?

For detailed model, dating and value information on vintage Montblanc writing instruments, The Montblanc Diary and Collectors Guide by Jens Rösler is the central reference. The book covers, among other things, rotary pencils and rotary fountain pens from the pre-war period and enables a well-founded identification. Supplementary hints and a book review can be found in the forum section on literature.


How are the first pictures of the Montblanc Writers Edition 2014 on William Faulkner to be judged?

The Writers Edition 2014 appears overall appealing, with especially the darker, contrasted nib pleasing, as is also a known stylistic device with other manufacturers. Critically seen is the newly designed grip section, since it lacks the ergonomic, curved form that, e.g., on the Meisterstück 146 is felt to be particularly pleasant. Thus the fountain pen leaves a mixed first impression.


Which Montblanc model is an old fountain pen with a digit in the turning-knob imprint, and is the writing instrument still everyday-suitable?

The piece described is most likely a Montblanc 344 or 324; the exact model number is usually in the imprint on the turning knob. Both models exist in two variants; the early version visible here falls in the period 1951 to 1953. These writing instruments count as reliable and are also today still everyday-suitable.


Which basic data and which collector value characterise the Montblanc push pencil 1646?

According to Collectible Stars by Jens Rösler and Stefan Wallrafen, the Montblanc 1646 was made from 1971 to 1973; it has a push mechanism, a matt-black plastic barrel with silver-plated tip, a matt-silver-plated cap as well as silver-plated clip and push head with a lead thickness of 0.92 mm. Today the model is fairly rare, since many examples were used until final wear. Near-new pieces achieve up to a maximum of about 100 euros and count primarily as a supplement to fountain pen and ballpoint, otherwise as a good utility writing instrument.


Which Cartier model is a writing instrument with a gilded cap?

A first, non-binding assessment points to the model Le Must de Cartier with gilded cap. A reliable identification is however not possible based solely on a photo. Further detail shots, especially of engravings and thread, can be helpful for a more precise determination.


Why does a Montblanc 234 1/2 sometimes have a brownish-discoloured end cap over the turning knob?

On Montblanc writing instruments of this time, housings are made of celluloid and end pieces of hard rubber. Hard rubber tends in the course of years to discolouration into brownish, which explains the colour difference between barrel and end cap. The discolouration is thus no defect but material-typical.